Sustainable Development Indicators



 

QUALITY OF LIFE IN JACKSONVILLE: INDICATORS FOR PROGRESS

INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW- http://www.jcci.org/qol/qol.htm

The Quality of Life project is based on a strong motivation for community improvement in Jacksonville/Duval County, Florida. This is an explicitly stated goal of the City of Jacksonville, the Jacksonville Chamber of Commerce, and the Jacksonville Community Council Inc. (JCCI). The project represents an effort to monitor Duval County's progress on an annual basis by means of selected representative quantitative indicators. Positive trends can be highlighted, recognized, and actively maintained; the beginnings of negative trends can be detected and action taken to address problems.

The quality of life is, admittedly, a vague and elusive concept. For the purposes of this study it refers to a feeling of well-being, fulfillment, or satisfaction resulting from factors in the external environments. For many people the quality of close interpersonal relationships, rather than the external environments, is the primary factor in determining happiness. Nevertheless, this project concentrates on the external environments, examining the quality of life from a community perspective.

 

 

 

CATEGORIES

 

INDICATOR

EDUCATION

  1. Public High-School Graduation Rate
  2. Average of Median Achievement Test Percentile Scores in Public Scools
  3. Public School educational expenditures per student
  4. Average public school teacher salary
  5. Percentage of public school teachers holding advanced degrees
  6. Percentage of higher education faculty holding terminal degrees
  7. Higher education degrees awarded
  8. Total student participation in credit/non-credit higher education programs

THE ECONOMY

  1. Net job growth
  2. Gap between total and black unemployment
  3. Effective buying income per capita
  4. Retail sales per capita
  5. Total taxable value of real estate
  6. New housing starts
  7. Affordability of a single-family home
  8. Percentage of public-school students participating in the free or reduced-cost lunch program
  9. Tourism as measured by Bed-Tax revenues
  10. Price of 1,000 kilowatt hours of electricity

PUBLIC SAFETY

  1. Percentage of people surveyed who report feeling safe walking alone at night in their neighborhood (telephone poll)
  2. Index crimes per 100,000 population
  3. Percentage of people surveyed who report having been victims of a crime within the last year (telephone poll)
  4. Average rescue call response time
  5. Average fire call response time
  6. Average Priority-One police call response time
  7. Resident deaths from accidents or poisoning per 100,000 population
  8. Motor vehicle accidents per 1,000 population

NATURAL ENVIRONMENT

 

 

NATURAL ENVIRONMENT Cont'd

  1. Number of days that the Air Quality Index is in the Good range
  2. Frequency of compliance in the St. Johns River and mouths of major tributaries with water standards for metals
  3. Frequency of compliance in the St. Johns River and tributary streams with water standards for dissolved oxygen
  4. Water level in Florida-Aquifer wells monitored by the City
  5. Average potable City water consumption per household account
  6. New septic-tank permits issued
  7. Sign permits issued
  8. Per-capita tons of solid waste deposited in City landfills

HEALTH

  1. Resident infant deaths per 1,000 live births
  2. Age-adjusted resident deaths per 100,000 population
  3. Resident deaths due to heart disease per 100,000 population
  4. Resident deaths due to lung cancer per 100,000 population
  5. Packs of cigarettes sold per capita
  6. Total newly diagnosed cases of AIDS per 100,000 population
  7. Alcohol use reported by youth
  8. Percentage of people surveyed who rate the health and medical-care system "good" or "excellent" (telephone poll)
  9. Percentage of people surveyed who report having no health insurance (telephone poll)

SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT

  1. Percentage of people surveyed who report that they believe racism to be a local problem (telephone poll)
  2. Substance-exposed newborns per 1,000 live births
  3. Substantiated reports of child abuse and neglect per 1,000 children under 18
  4. Resident live births to females under 18 per 1,000 live births
  5. Employment-discrimination complaints filed with the Jacksonville Equal Opportunity Commission
  6. Percentage of people surveyed who report having volunteered time in the community during the past year (telephone poll)

GOVERNMENT/ POLITICS

  1. Percentage of people surveyed who rate the quality of local-government leadership "good" or "excellent" (telephone poll)
  2. Percentage of population 18 and over registered to vote
  3. Percentage of registered voters who vote in scheduled general elections
  4. Percentage of elected officials who are people of color
  5. Percentage of elected officials who are female
  6. Percentage of people surveyed who can name two current City Council members (telephone poll)
  7. Percentage of people surveyed who report keeping up with local government news "frequently" (telephone poll)
  8. Percentage of people surveyed who feel that local public services are effectively provided frequently" (telephone poll)

CULTURE/ RECREATION

  1. City financial support per capita of arts organizations
  2. City parks and recreation operating expenditures per capita
  3. Public park acreage per 1,000 population
  4. Public library materials per capita
  5. Public library book circulation per capita
  6. Total event/days of bookings at major City facilities
  7. Symphony attendance per 1,000 population
  8. Zoo attendance per 1,000 population

MOBILITY

  1. Percentage of working people surveyed who report commuting times of 25 minutes or less (telephone poll)
  2. Total weekday commercial flights in and out of the Jacksonville International Airport
  3. Destinations served by direct flights to and from the Jacksonville International Airport
  4. Average weekday ridership per 1,000 population on Jacksonville Transportation Authority buses
  5. Average weekday miles of Jacksonville Transportation Authority bus service
  6. Percentage of JTA bus headways within 30 minutes during peak hours and 60 minutes during nonpeak hours

 

 

 

SUSTAINABLE CITY- Working Towards a Sustainable Future for San Francisco

http://www.sustainable-city.org/

 

CATEGORIES

INDICATORS

AIR QUALITY

  1. Number of existing buildings that join the Building Air Quality Alliance Program (or similar voluntary programs).
  2. Number of people going to clinics for respiratory problems.
  3. Percentage of new cars registered in San Francisco which are alternatively fueled (e.g., California Air Resources Board-certified, low emission vehicles, ultra-low emission vehicles, or electric vehicles).

BIODIVERSITY

  1. Number of volunteer hours dedicated towards managing, monitoring, and conserving San Franciscos biodiversity.
  2. Number of square feet of the worst invasive species removed from natural areas.
  3. Number of surviving indigenous native plant species planted in developed parks, private landscapes and natural areas.
  4. Abundance and species diversity of birds, as indicated by the Golden Gate Audubon Societys Christmas bird counts.

ENERGY, CLIMATE AND OZONE DEPLETION

  1. Ratio of renewable to non-renewable energy consumption.
  2. Energy cost per tax dollar.

FOOD AND AGRICULTURE

  1. Number of public agricultural gardens.
  2. Quantity of food and agricultural residuals recycled.
  3. Number of school, vocational and community education and training programs about sustainable agriculture and nutrition.

HAZARDOUS MATERIALS

  1. Difference between motor oil purchased in the City and the amount that is properly recycled or disposed.
  2. Equitable distribution of the hazardous material/waste exposure "load" throughout the City.
  3. Number of contaminated sites within City borders.
  4. Public awareness of hazardous materials/waste issues (especially proper use and disposal and knowledge of alternatives) as measured by annual survey (to measure effectiveness of outreach).

ECONOMY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

  1. Number of San Francisco enterprises adopting ISO 14000 standards.
  2. Number of San Francisco neighborhoods with unemployment rates higher than the government-defined "full employment" rate.
  3. Difference between the highest neighborhood unemployment rate and the full employment rate.
  4. Number of San Francisco manufacturers using recovered secondary materials as raw material.
  5. Percentage of people employed in San Francisco who live in San Francisco.

HUMAN HEALTH

  1. New cases of asthma.
  2. Number of people attending organized wellness classes.
  3. Participation in organized youth programs at city recreation centers.

PARKS AND OPEN SPACES

  1. Percentage of the population with a recreational facility and a natural setting within a ten-minute walk.
  2. Number of neighborhood green street corridors created annually.
  3. Number of volunteer hours spent annually on maintenance of open space.
  4. Annual municipal expenditures on parks, open space, and streetscapes.

SOLID WASTE

  1. Tons of waste landfilled annually.
  2. Recycling rate as a percentage of material generated.
  3. Percentage of residents, businesses, and institutions that participate in recycling programs.

TRANSPORTATION

  1. Auto registration.
  2. Parking-spot inventory.
  3. Muni ridership.
  4. Muni route running time on key routes.

WATER & WASTE WATER

  1. Per capita water consumption measured by the San Francisco Water Department.
  2. Mass of pollutants in wastewater.
  3. Mass and frequency of combined sewer overflows.
  4. Recycled water use.
  5. Acres of habitat restored.

MUNICIPAL EXPENDITURES

  1. Number of items of legislation adopted by the Board of Supervisors that advance sustainability goals.
  2. Number of service providers and companies on the Green Vendors list.
  3. Percentage of budget allocated utilizing sustainability criteria.
  4. Percentage of budget that is devoted to facility maintenance.

PUBLIC INFO & EDUCATION

  1. Number of schools that integrate and progressively update environmental education in their curricula.
  2. Conservation and waste reduction as measured by volume of garbage produced per capita and units of electricity used per capita.
  3. Number of volunteers working on environmental projects as measured through the largest volunteer clearinghouse that refers or mobilizes people to do community service.

ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE

  1. Mean income level of people in historically disadvantaged communities.
  2. Proportion of environmental pollution sources in historically disadvantaged communities with respect to San Francisco's other communities.
  3. Participation of historically disadvantaged communities as a whole and their indigenous self-selected representatives in decision-making processes.

RISK MANAGEMENT (ACTIVITIES OF HIGH ENVIRONMENTAL RISK)

  1. Number of businesses that train employees in the Neighborhood Emergency Response Teams program.
  2. Number of seismically upgraded buildings.
  3. Number of hazardous materials incidents.

 

 

 

Santa Barbara South Coast Community Indicators 1998/1999 Report

http://www.grc.org/indicators/9899report.htm

Community Indicators Project. This project is the result of a community effort that tracks the social, environmental and economic factors that make up the Santa Barbara South Coast. The mission statement of the indicators project is:

To involve the Santa Barbara South Coast Community in developing and using social, environmental, and economic indicators that will guide decisions towards continually improving our quality of life. We have provided the source of the data for each indicator so you can learn more about how the information was developed. In many cases, the web page version (www.grc.org/indicators) provides links to these and other data sources, which allows you to find out more about the South Coast community. Some indicators also have an In The Future section that discusses data we would like to include in future documents.

 

CATEGORIES

INDICATORS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SOCIAL INDICATORS

Individual and family well-being

  1. Domestic Violence Cases With a Weapon
  2. The number of children born to women under the age of 18 per 1,000 births
  3. The percentage of students participating in federally sponsored school lunch programs in local public elementary schools.

Neighbourhood and Community well-being

  1. The square footage of available City and County parks on the South Coast on a per capita basis.
  2. The number of juvenile felony arrests including homicide, forcible rape, aggravated assault and larceny.
  3. The number of property and violent crimes per one thousand people. Property crimes include burglary, larceny-theft, and motor vehicle theft. Violent crimes include murder, non-negligent manslaughter, rape, robbery and assault.

Public Health

  1. The number of drug related deaths per 10,000 people
  2. The number of expectant mothers per 1,000 births who did not receive adequate prenatal care within the first three months of their pregnancy.
  3. The number of suicide related deaths per 10,000 people.

Education

  1. SAT Scores
  2. High-school drop-out rates

Civic Engagement

  1. The total real dollars collected by the United Way during its annual campaign
  2. The number of registered and the percentage of registered voters who voted in the election.

Arts

  1. The total attendance and number of shows at the Theater and the Opera.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ECONOMIC INDICATORS

Standard of Living

  1. The ratio of total personal income to total population
  2. The sum of total wages and salaries paid to all workers divided by the total number of wage and salary earning employees.

Job Quantity and Quality

  1. The rate of change of employment in non-farm wage and salary jobs
  2. The rate of creation of higher paying jobs: This measurement compares the number of jobs created in industries that have above average wages to those created in industries that have below average wages.

Housing Affordability

  1. An estimate of the percentage of households in the County that can afford to own a median priced home: This index assumes that the average household will finance a purchase with an 80 percent loan and will use no more than 30 percent of its income on housing expenses.
  2. An estimate of the percentage of households in the County that can afford to rent an average priced rental unit: this index assumes that households can use up to 50 percent of their income for rent.

Business Vitality

  1. The percentage of South Coast businesses that feel business conditions are improving.
  2. The total office, industrial, and retail space available for lease

Economic Resilience

  1. The number of industries creating jobs, in comparison to the total number of industries. This index monitors job creation in the 11 principle industries that comprise the local economy: agriculture; construction; finance, insurance, and real estate; durable manufacturing; nondurable manufacturing; oil and gas extraction; retail trade; wholesale trade; services; transportation and public utilities; and state and local government.

Targeted Industries

  1. The number of jobs provided by companies in key industries that have been targeted as desirable. These industries include communications equipment manufacturing, software development and medical devices manufacturing.

Government

  1. The ratio of state and local government workers per 1,000 residents. This measurement does not include school employees.

 

 

 

 

 

 

ENVIRONMENTAL INDICATORS

 

 

 

 

 

 

Water Quality

  1. The percentage of water quality tests that exceeded state and federal standards for fecal coliform and enterococcus as a percentage of overall tests.

Air Quality

  1. The number of days in which communities did not meet the state standard for ozone levels.

Ground and Ground Water Contamination

  1. The total pounds of pesticide used in agriculture throughout the County.

Land Use

  1. The total number of acres covered by urban development

Mobility

  1. The percentage of South Coast commuters traveling alone to and from work by automobile in peak traffic hours.
  2. The number of bus trips taken by residents on the Transit buses

Resource Use

  1. The total tons of waste disposed of annually in the landfill

Natural Community

  1. An index summarizing the results of the Audubon Society's annual Christmas Bird Count

 

New Jersey- http://www.njfuture.org/HTMLSrc/SSR/GoalsAndIndicators.html

New Jersey Future proposes, for discussion, twenty measures of sustainability that span the three systems that support human life; economy, environment and society. The intersections of these systems, shown here, suggest the public values of health, equity and efficiency. The measures were selected and ordered so as to represent the full scope of New Jerseys future well-being. They begin with the well-being of the individual, unfolding outward to include the well-being of the community, then of the natural environment and the economy. Among the last are measures that reveal exported impacts such as those attributable to waste generation; and those that reveal external dependencies such as fuel consumption.

 

GOALS

INDICATORS

ECONOMIC VITALITY

  1. Income: Average annual disposable income
  2. Unemployment: Percent of the state's total labor force unemployed
  3. Productivity: The amount of Gross State Product produced per laborer
  4. Poverty: Percent of New Jerseyans who fall below the official poverty level:
  5. Gross State Product in dollars per year
  6. Energy Efficiency: Economic output per unit of energy consumed

Equity

  1. Equal Pay: Median hourly wages by gender and race
  2. Legislator's Reflection of Population: Percent of women, blacks and Latinos serving in the 120-member State Legislature
  3. Disparities in infant mortality (deaths per 1,000 births) for the total population and the black population

Strong Community, Culture and Recreation

  1. Newspaper Circulation: The per capita circulation of newspapers
  2. Crime Rate: Number of reported violent and non-violent crimes per 1,000 people
  3. Acres of open space preserved for public recreation

Quality Education

  1. Graduation Rates: Percentage of students who graduate within four years of entering high school
  2. Student/Teacher ratio: Average number of students per full-time classroom teacher at public schools
  3. Standardized Test Scores: Percent of students meeting the minimum high school proficiency mandated by the state
  4. Access to Higher Education: Undergraduate enrollment in New Jersey colleges and universities

Good Government

  1. Knowledge of Government: Percent of survey respondents who knew which party was in control of the State Legislature
  2. Voter Turnout: Percent of registered voters casting ballots in statewide general elections

Decent Housing

  1. Rent Affordability: Percent of New Jersey renters able to afford the fair market rent with 30 percent of their income
  2. Home Prices Versus Income: The relationship between average per capita annual income for a four-person family and median home sale prices
  3. Housing Choice: The 10 fastest-growing residential areas in New Jersey according to their location in urban, suburban, or rural settings

Healthy People

  1. Life Expectancy: Average number of years of life
  2. Infectious Diseases: The rate of occurrence of newly reported cases of tuberculosis, AIDS and syphilis
  3. Asthma: Number of reported hospital admissions for asthma per 100,000 people
  4. Workplace Fatalities: Job fatalities per 100,000 workers

Efficient Transportation and Land Use

  1. Need for Road and Bridge Repairs: The accumulated cost of repair work necessary to bring New Jersey's roads and bridges up to standard
  2. Vehicle Miles Traveled: Annual vehicle miles traveled (VMT) on New Jersey's road system per capita
  3. Workplace Transportation Options: Cumulative number of transit-friendly and auto-dependent large office developments built since 1990
  4. Traffic fatalities: Annual number of reported deaths from traffic accidents involving motorists or pedestrians

Natural and Ecological Integrity

  1. Fresh Water Wetland Losses: The acres of fresh water wetlands lost to permitted development each year
  2. Nesting Water Bird Populations: Population of nesting colonies of water birds
  3. River Health/ Dissolved Oxygen: Number of testing stations (total of 66) reporting adequate dissolved oxygen 90 percent or more of the time
  4. Marine Water Quality: Percent of shellfish habitat safe for harvesting

Protected Natural Resources

  1. Energy Consumption: Annual energy consumption
  2. Farmland: Total acres of farmland in New Jersey
  3. Beach and Bay Closings: Number of times per year a New Jersey beach or bay has been closed to the public due to hazardous conditions
  4. Preserved and Developed Land: Number of acres preserved or developed

Minimal Pollution and Waste

  1. Greenhouse Gas and Release: Millions of tons of greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere annually (expressed as carbon dioxide equivalent weight)
  2. Drinking Water Quality: The percent of public drinking water systems which tested within allowable levels for all chemicals for which testing is conducted
  3. Total Solid waste Production: Pounds of solid waste generated annually, per New Jersey resident
  4. Air Pollution: Number of unhealthful days annually caused by ground-level ozone, particulate matter and carbon monoxide

Oregon Shines: Oregon - http://www.econ.state.or.us/opb/ and http://www.econ.state.or.us/opb/benchmark_tables/index.htm

In 1989, the Oregon Progress Board was formed to implement and monitor strategies developed in a broad 20 year vision for Oregons strategic development called "Oregon Shines". The Board established "Benchmarks" as a system for monitoring progress from year to year and decade to decade.

CATEGORIES

INDICATORS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ECONOMY

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ECONOMY cont'd

Business Vitality

  1. Percentage of Oregonians employed outside the Willamette Valley and the Portland tri-county area
  2. Percentage of professional services exported (imported) relative to Oregon's industry demand
  3. Oregon's national rank in new companies
  4. Oregon's national rank in traded sector strength
  5. Oregon's national rank in business closings
  6. Net job growth
  7. Oregon's national rank in economic diversification

Economic Capacity

  1. Industry research and development expenditures as a percentage of gross state product
  2. Oregon's national rank in venture capital investments

Business Costs

  1. Oregon's rank among seven Western states in business taxes as a percentage of gross state product
  2. Oregon's national rank in health care costs
  3. Oregon's national rank in workers' compensation costs
  4. Percentage of permits issued within the target time period or less
    1. Air contaminant discharge

b. Wastewater discharge

Income

  1. Per capita personal income as a percentage of the U.S. per capita income
  2. Average annual payroll per covered worker (all industries, 1995 dollars)
  3. Percentage of Oregonians in the middle income range
  4. Percentage of covered Oregon workers with earnings of 150% or more of poverty at a rate for a family of four)
  5. Unemployment rate (civilian labor force, annual average)

International

  1. Number of international cities of over 1 million population (outside Canada and Mexico) served by direct or non-stop flights to and from any Oregon commercial airport
  2. 20. Percentage of Oregonians who speak a language in addition to English

 

 

 

 

 

 

Education

Kindergarten - 12

  1. Percentage of children entering school ready-to-learn
  2. High school dropout rate
  3. Percentage of 8th graders who achieve established skill levels

a. Reading

b. Math

24. Percentage of 3rd graders who achieve established skill levels

a. Reading

    1. Math

25. Percentage of high school students completing a structured work experience

Post Secondary

  1. 26. Percentage of Oregon adults (25+) who have completed a college degree
  2. Percentage of Oregon adults (25+) completing high school or equivalent
  3. Percentage of Oregon adults (25+) who have completed some college
  4. Percentage of Oregon adults (25+) completed associate degree

Skill Development

30. Percentage of all adult Oregonians with intermediate literacy skills

a. Prose

b. Document

c. Quantitative

  1. Percentage of Oregonians who report they use a computer to create, edit documents/graphics, to analyze data
  2. Percentage of labor force receiving at least 20 hours of skills training in the past year

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Civic Engagement

Participation

  1. Percentage of Oregonians who volunteer at least 50 hours of their time per year to civic, community or, nonprofit activities
  2. Percentage of eligible Oregonians who vote
  3. Percentage of Oregonians who feel they are a part of their community

Taxes

  1. Percentage of Oregonians who understand the Oregon tax system and where tax money is spent
  2. State and local taxes per capita (1995 dollars)

a. As a percentage of 1990

b. Oregon's rank

38. State and local taxes per $1,000 of personal income

    1. As a percentage of 1990
    2. Oregon's rank

Public Sector Performance

  1. Public management quality
  2. State general obligation bond rating (Standard and Poors)

Culture

  1. Oregon's national rank in per capita state arts funding
  2. 42. Percentage of Oregonians served by a public library which meets minimum service criteria

 

social support

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Social Support cont'd

Health

  1. Pregnancy rate per 1,000 females age 10-17
  2. Percentage of babies whose mothers received early prenatal care (beginning in the first trimester)
  3. Infant mortality rate per 1,000
  4. Percentage of two-year-olds who are adequately immunized
  5. Annual percentage of new HIV cases with an early diagnosis (before symptoms occur)
  6. Percentage of adults who do not currently smoke tobacco
  7. Premature Mortality: Years of potential life lost before age 70 (rate per 1,000)
  8. Percentage of adults whose self-perceived health status is very good or excellent
  9. Percentage of families for whom child care is affordable
  10. Number of child care slots available for every 100 children under age 13

Protection

53. Percentage of 8th grade students who report using:

    1. Alcohol in the previous month
    2. Illicit drugs in the previous month
    3. Cigarettes in the previous month
  1. Number of children abused or neglected per 1,000 persons under 18
  2. Reported elder abuse rate per 1,000
  3. Percentage of infants whose mothers used:

a. Alcohol during pregnancy (self-reported by mother)

b. Tobacco during pregnancy (self-reported by mother)

Poverty

  1. Percentage of Oregonians with incomes below 100% of the Federal poverty level
  2. Percentage of Oregonians without health insurance
  3. Number of Oregonians that are homeless on any given night
  4. Percentage of current court ordered child support paid to families

Independent Living

  1. Percentage of seniors living independently
  2. Percentage of Oregonians with a disability able to live on their own with adequate support
  3. Percentage of Oregonians with a disability living in households with incomes below the federal poverty level

 

 

 

 

 

Valley Vital Signs: http://www.vitalcommunities.org/vvs.htm

As the indicator project of Vital Communities in the Upper Valley region of Vermont and New Hampshire, Valley Vital signs sets goals and benchmarks in the areas of Nature/Environment, Economy, Well-being, and Society/Community.

 

 

 

Goals and Benchmarks

Indicators

Nature/ Environment

  1. Number of species of nesting birds
  2. An indicator measuring sprawl
  3. The quality of our rivers, streams, ponds and lakes
  4. Success of farms
  5. Valley Transportation: vehicle miles traveled vs. Advanced Transit ridership population trends

Economy

  1. Wage trends vs. rents and the cost of buying a house
  2. Variety of jobs offered in different industries and occupations
  3. Trained labor pool available to businesses
  4. Number of patents issued
  5. Percent of locally owned businesses

 

Well-Being

  1. Youth:
    1. percent of 11th graders who smoke cigarettes weekly and percent who attain a high school degree by age 25
    2. Percent of babies born at a healthy weight
    3. Percent of 2nd and 3rd graders who can read (An indicator reflecting the success of arts and culture
  1. An indicator of adult health

Society/Community

  1. Town center vitality:
    1. number of post offices located in town centers
    2. number of vacant store fronts on main streets
  1. Percent of youth who volunteer
  2. Voter turnout at local elections
  3. Miles of public trails and roads for hiking, bike riding, and snowmobiling (An indicator of neighborliness and/or isolation)

 

"Measuring Up". Alberta, Canada http://www.treas.gov.ab.ca/comm/perfmeas/measup99/index.html

In 1994, the Government of Alberta, Canada initiated a program called "Measuring Up" to monitor progress toward sustainability goals and to create a framework for government accountability. The program established 23 "core measurements," or indicators for goals in three broad categories :PEOPLE / PROSPERITY/ PRESERVATION

 

 

Categories

Indicators

People

  1. Life Expectancy at Birth
  2. Health Status
  3. Births to Mothers under Age 18
  4. Educational Attainment: The percentage of students graduating from high school within 6 years of entering grade 9
  5. Literacy and Numeracy Levels: grade 9 language arts results and acceptable standard for mathematics
  6. Family Income Distribution: The percentage of families with incomes less than $20,000

Prosperity

  1. Gross Domestic Product
  2. Job Growth: net new jobs created
  3. Skill Development: labour force productivity
  4. Adoption of New Technologies: Alberta business funding of research and development as a percentage of Canadian business funding
  5. Cost of Government: Per capita spending by the Alberta government
  6. Infrastructure Capacity
  7. Taxation Load
  8. Provincial Credit Rating
  9. Net Debt
  10. Workplace Climate: lost person-days per 10,000 person-days worked to disputes; The rate of person-days lost to injury and disease
  11. Export Trade

Preservation

  1. Crime Rate
  2. Resource Sustainability: timber harvest; conventional oil reserves; crop yield on agricultural land
  3. Air Quality
  4. Water Quality
  5. Land Quality: land productivity, expressed as crop yield per acre
  6. Heritage Appreciation: visitation to natural historical and cultural sites
  7. Intergovernmental Relations

Agenda 21- United Nations gopher://gopher.un.org/00esc/cn17/1995/off/95-18.en

In 1992, the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), better known as the Earth Summit, was held in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Over 170 countries cooperated to produce treaties on climate change and biological diversity, a set of forestry principles, and an extensive plan called Agenda 21 for sustainable development now and into the 21st century.

Within Agenda 21 is a proposal to develop indicators for sustainable development. The objective is to make indicators accessible worldwide to decision makers at the national level by defining sustainability indicators, elucidating their methodologies, and providing training and other capacity-building activities.

 

Category

Indicators

 

 

Social

 

Driving force indicators

State indicators:

Response indicators:

Agenda 21 Chapter 3: Poverty

  • Employment rate (%)
  • Ratio of average female wage to average male wage
  • Population living in absolute poverty (no. and %)
  • Gini coefficient of income
 
       

Agenda 21 Chapter 5: Demographic dynamics and sustainability

  • Population growth rate (%)
  • Net migration rate (people/year)
  • Population density (people per km2)
  • Total fertility rate
       

Agenda 21 Chapter 36: Promoting education, public awareness and training (including gender issues)

  • Rate of growth of school age population
  • Primary school enrolment ratio (%)
  • Secondary school enrolment ratio (%)
  • Adult literacy rate (%)
  • Population reaching grade 5 of primary education (%)
  • Mean number of years of schooling
  • % of GDP spent on education
  • Females per 100 males in secondary school (no.)
  • Women per 100 men in the labour force (%)
       

Agenda 21 Chapter 6: Protecting and promoting human health

  • % of people without access to sufficient and safe drinking water
  • % of people without access to adequate sanitation
  • % of people exposed to high concentrations of health damaging air pollution
  • % of people without adequate food supply
  • Infant mortality rate (per 1,000 live births)
  • Life expectancy at birth (years)
  • Maternal mortality rate (per 1,000 live births)
  • % GDP spent on health
  • % of population covered by primary health care
  • % of eligible population that have been fully immunized against key communicable diseases
  • % of women of child-bearing age using/with access to family planning
  • % of national health expenditure devoted to local health services
       

Agenda 21 Chapter 7: Human settlements (including traffic and transport)

  • Rate of growth of urban population (%)
  • Transport fuel consumption per capita (l)
  • Number of megacities (10 mill. or more)
  • % of population in urban areas
  • Area and population of marginal settlements (km2, no.)
  • Cost/number of injuries and fatalities related to natural disasters b/ (US$, no.)
  • Floor area per person (m2)
  • House price to income ratio
  • Expenditure on low-cost housing (US$)
  • Expenditure on public transportation (US$)
  • Infrastructure expenditures per capita (US$)
  • The housing credit portfolio
  •        

    ECONOMIC

         

    Agenda 21 Chapter 2: International cooperation

    • Real GDP per capita growth rate (%)
    • Exports of goods and services (US$)
    • Imports of goods and services (US$)
  • GDP per capita (US$)
  • EDP per capita/environmentally adjusted value added (US$)
  • Share of manufacturing value added in GDP (%)
  • Export concentration ratio (%)
  • Investment share in GDP (%)
  • Participation in regional trade agreements (yes/no)
  •        

    Agenda 21 Chapter 4: Consumption and production patterns

    • Depletion of mineral resources (% of proven reserves)
    • Annual energy consumption per capita (J)
  • Proven mineral reserves (t)
  • Proven energy reserves (oil equivalents)
  • Lifetime of proven energy reserves (years)
  • Share of natural-resource intensive industries in manufacturing value added (%)
  • Share of manufactures in merchandise exports (%)
  • Ratio of consumption of renewable resources over non- renewable resources (%)
  •        

    Agenda 21 Chapter 33: Financial resources and mechanisms

    • Ratio of net resource transfer/GDP (%)
  • Total ODA given or received as percentage of GDP (%)
  • Debt/GDP (%)
  • Debt service/export (%)
  • Environmental protection expenditure as % of GDP
  • Environmental taxes and subsidies as % of government revenue
  • Amount of new or additional funding for sustainable development given/received since 1992 (US$)
  • Programme of integrated environmental and economic accounting (yes/no)
  • Debt relief
  •        

    Agenda 21 Chapter 34: Transfer of technology

    ------

    ------

    ------

           

    ENVIRONMENTAL

         

    Water

    Agenda 21 Chapter 18: Freshwater resources

    • Annual withdrawals of ground and surface water as % of available water
    • Domestic consumption of water per capita (m3)
  • Groundwater reserves (m3)
  • Concentration of faecal coliform in freshwater bodies (no./100 ml)
  • BOD and COD in water bodies (mg/l)
  • Waste water treatment (% of population served, total and by type of treatment
  • Agenda 21 Chapter 17: Protection of the oceans, all kinds of seas and coastal areas

    • Catches of marine species (t)
    • Population growth in coastal areas (%)
    • Discharges of oil into coastal waters (t)
    • Releases of N and P to coastal waters (t)
  • Deviation in stock of marine species from maximum sustained yield level (MSY) (%)
  • Ratio between MSY abundance and actual average abundance(%)
  • Algae index
  • Participation in maritime treaties/agreements (yes/no)
  •        

    Land

    Agenda 21 Chapter 10: Planning and management of land resources

    • Land use
  • Area affected by soil erosion (km2)/erosion index
  • Land reform policy (yes/no)
  • Decentralized local level natural resource management (yes/no)
  •        

    Agenda 21 Chapter 12: Combating desertification and drought

    • Fuelwood consumption per capita (m3)
    • Livestock levels per km2 in dryland
    • Population living below poverty line in dryland areas (%)
    • Land affected by desertification (km2)/desertification index
    • Drought frequency

    -----

           

    Agenda 21 Chapter 13: Sustainable mountain development

    ------

    -------

    ------

           

    Agenda 21 Chapter 14: Promoting sustainable agriculture and rural development

    • Use of agricultural pesticides (t/km2)
    • Use of fertilizers (t/km2)
    • Arable land per capita (ha/capita)
    • Irrigation % of arable land
  • Area affected by salinization and waterlogging (km2)
  • Cost of extension services provided and cost of agricultural research (US$)
  • Area of land reclaimed (km2)
  •        

    Other natural resources

    Agenda 21 Chapter 11: Combating deforestation

    Deforestation rate (km2/annum)

    Annual roundwood production (m3)

    Timber stocks (m3)

    Forest area (km2)

    Wood as % of energy consumption

    Reforestation rate (km2/annum)

    Protected forest area as % of total land area

           

    Agenda 21 Chapter 15: Conservation of biological diversity

    ------

    • Threatened, extinct species (no.)
  • Protected area as % of total land area
  •        

    Agenda 21 Chapter 16: Biotechnology

    -----

    ------

    ------

           

    Atmosphere

    Agenda 21 Chapter 9: Protection of the atmosphere

    • Emissions of CO2 (t)
    • Emissions of SOx and NOx (t)
    • Consumption of ozone depleting substances (t)
  • Ambient concentrations of SO2, CO, NOx, O3 and TSP in urban areas (ppm)
  • Expenditure on air pollution abatement (US$)
  • Reductions in the emissions of CO2, SOx and NOx (% per year)
  •        

    Waste

    Agenda 21 Chapter 21: Solid wastes and sewage-related issues

    • Generation of industrial and municipal waste (t)
  • Waste disposal/capita (t)
  • Expenditure on waste collection and treatment (US$)
  • Waste recycling rates (%)
  • Municipal waste disposal (t/capita)
  • Waste reduction rates per unit of GDP (t/year)
  •        

    Agenda 21 Chapter 19: Toxic Chemicals

    -----

    ------

    ------

           

    Agenda 21 Chapter 20, 22: Hazardous wastes

    • Generation of hazardous waste (t)
    • Imports and exports of hazardous waste (t)
  • Area of land contaminated by hazardous waste (km2)
  • Expenditure on hazardous waste treatment (US$)
  •        

    Agenda 21 Chapter 35: Science

    ------

    ------

    -----

           

    Agenda 21 Chapter 37: Capacity-building

    -----

    -----

    ------

           

    Agenda 21 Chapter 8, 38, 39, 40: Decision-making structures

    -----

    • Mandated EIA (yes/no)
    • Programmes for national environmental statistics and indicators for sustainable development (yes/no)
    • Sustainable development strategies (yes/no)
    • National councils for sustainable development (yes/no)
    • Main telephone lines per 100 inhabitants (no.)
  • Ratification of international agreements related to sustainable development (no.)
  • Number of local government employees per 1000 population (no.)
  • Personnel expenditure ratio (proportion of recurrent
  • expenditure spent on wage costs)(%)
  •        

    Agenda 21: Strengthening of "traditional information" (Part of ch.40)

    ------

    Representatives of indigenous people in national councils for sustainable development (yes/no)

    Existence of database for traditional knowledge information (yes/no)

    -----

           

    Agenda 21 Chapter 23-32: Role of major groups

    ------

    Representatives of major groups in national councils for sustainable development (yes/no)

    ------

           

     

     

    European Commission, Eurostat and Joint Research Centre Institute for Systems, Informatics and Safety (ISIS) Environmental & Sustainable Development indicators: http://esl.jrc.it/envind/

    http://esl.jrc.it/envind/hm_me_en.htm

    Indicator list Eurostat Environmental Pressure Indices Project, Version EN

     

     

     

    Category

    Indicators

    AIR POLLUTION

     

     

     

     

     

    Air Pollution cONT'D

    1. Emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx)
    2. Emissions of non-methane volatile organic compounds (NMVOCs)
    3. Emissions of sulfur dioxide (SO2)
    4. Emissions of particles
    5. Consumption of gasoline & diesel oil by road vehicles
    6. Primary energy consumption
    7. Emissions of ammonia (NH3)
    8. Emissions of selected persistent organic pollutants (POPs)
    9. Use of pesticides for agricultural purposes
    10. Electricity consumption

     

     

    Climate Change

    1. Emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2)
    2. Emissions of methane (CH4)
    3. Emissions of nitrous oxide (N2O)
    4. Emissions of chloro­fluoro­carbons (CFCs)
    5. Emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx)
    6. Emissions of sulfur oxides (SOx)
    7. Emissions of particles
    8. Removals of carbon dioxide (CO2)
    9. Emissions of non-methane volatile organic compounds (NMVOCs)
    10. Emissions of hydro­chloro­fluoro­carbons (HCFCs)

     

     

    Loss of Biodiversity

    1. Protected area loss, damage and fragmentation
    2. Wetland loss through drainage
    3. Agriculture intensity: area used for intensive arable agriculture
    4. Fragmentation of forests & landscapes by roads/intersections
    5. Clearance of natural & semi-natural forested areas
    6. Change in traditional land-use practice
    7. Loss of genetic resources - non-utilization of available crop species & varieties
    8. Pesticide use on land
    9. Loss of forest diversity - increase in exotic monoculture
    10. Riverbank loss through artificialization

     

     

    Marine Environment & Coastal Zones

    1. Eutrophication
    2. Overfishing
    3. Development along shore
    4. Priority habitat loss
    5. Discharges of heavy metals
    6. Oil pollution at coast & at sea
    7. Discharges of halogenated organic compounds
    8. Wetland loss
    9. Tourism intensity
    10. Fecal pollution

     

     

    Ozone Layer Depletion

    1. Emissions of bromo­fluoro­carbons (halons)
    2. Emissions of chloro­fluoro­carbons (CFCs)
    3. Emissions of hydro­chloro­fluoro­carbons (HCFCs)
    4. Emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2)
    5. Emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx)
    6. Emissions of chlorinated carbons
    7. Emissions of methyl bromide (CH3Br)
    8. Emissions of methane (CH4)
    9. Emissions of nitrous oxide (N2O)
    10. Emissions of methyl chloroform (CH3CCl3)

     

     

    Resource Depletion

    1. Water consumption per capita (incl. ground water abstraction)
    2. Use of energy per capita
    3. Increase in territory permanently occupied by urbanization; infrastructure; waste-tipping & quarrying
    4. Nutrient-balance of the soil (nutrient input/nutrient output)
    5. Electricity production from fossil fuels (mineral oil, natural gas & coal)
    6. Timber balance (new growth/harvest)
    7. Use of mineral oil as a fuel
    8. Surface water abstraction (for drinking water/agriculture/ industry)
    9. Exceedance of fish catch quota
    10. Ground water abstraction for agricultural/industrial purposes

     

     

    Dispersion of Toxic Substances

    1. Consumption of pesticides by agriculture
    2. Emissions of persistent organic pollutants (POPs)
    3. Consumption of toxic chemicals
    4. Index of heavy metal emissions to water
    5. Index of heavy metal emissions to air
    6. Emissions of radioactive material
    7. Emissions of heavy metals by consumption
    8. Production of chlorinated compounds
    9. Consumption of household toxic chemicals
    10. Vehicle distribution by technology type & fuel

     

     

    Urban Environmental Problems

    1. Energy consumption
    2. Non-recycled municipal waste
    3. Non-treated wastewater
    4. Share of private car transport
    5. People endangered by noise emissions
    6. Land use (change from natural to built-up area)
    7. Inhabitants per green area
    8. Water consumption per capita
    9. Emissions of sulfur dioxide (SO2) & nitrogen oxides (NOx)
    10. Derelict areas

     

     

    Waste

    1. Waste landfilled
    2. Waste incinerated
    3. Hazardous waste
    4. Municipal waste
    5. Waste per product during a number of products' entire lifetime
    6. Waste recycled/material recovered
    7. Waste from other economic sectors
    8. Consumption of hazardous materials
    9. Waste from energy production
    10. Waste disposed to sea

     

     

    Water Pollution & Water Resources

    1. Nutrient (nitrogen & phosphorus - N + P) use (eutrophication equivalents)
    2. Ground water abstraction
    3. Pesticides used per hectare of agriculture area
    4. Water treated/water collected
    5. Index of heavy metals emissions
    6. Emissions of organic matter as biochemical oxygen demand (BOD)
    7. Industrial water uses
    8. Waste water collected/water use
    9. Households & public utilities water use
    10. Water recycling by industry

     

    Franklin County Indicators of Sustainable Development: http://www.mainewest.com/indicators/Indicators/indicators.html

    The Northern New England Sustainable Communities Project is a partnership between NHCF, the Maine Community Foundation, the Vermont Community Foundation and the Ford Foundation to support community leaders in enhancing the long-term economic viability of their communities while preserving or enhancing the environmental quality of these communities. Additional project goals are to expand the capacity of community foundations to partner with rural communities to achieve sustainable economic development and to develop new understanding about how sustainable economic development can be fostered in rural communities. To participate in this project, communities must agree to work toward such principles as developing broad community participation, strengthening community infrastructure, focusing on attainable goals, leveraging volunteer talents and time, seeking regional solutions, and working innovatively. (from the New Hampshire Community Foundation)

     

     

     

     

    Categories

    Indicators

     

    Sustainable Environment

     

    Land : Percent of Land in Agricultural Production

    Water : Acres of Lakes Partially Impaired or Threatened

    Trees : Volume of Sawtimber Trees

    Sustainable Economy

    Poverty : Percent of Households below the Poverty Level

    Jobs : Manufacturing Jobs as a Percent of All Jobs

    Tourism : Hotels and Other Lodging Employment

    Roads : Percent of Minor Arterial Roads Needing Repair

    Sustainable Community

    Health : Percent of Deaths that are Preventable

    Education : Percent of High School Grads Going on to Post-Secondary Education

    Diversity : Gender Mix Among Town Leaders

    Democracy : Number of Town Meetings with Increasing Attendance

    Mainstreets : Vacancy Rate of Store Fronts in Community Centers

     

    Indicators for a Sustainable San Mateo County. A Yearly Report Card on Our County's Quality of Life. May 1999: http://sustainable.advocate.net/99indicators/default.htm

    The 1999 Indicators Report is San Mateo County's third annual report card on quality of life. The Indicators report presents a snapshot of the quality of life in San Mateo County in 1999, and compares it with previous snapshots from 1997 and 1998. Each entry is presented in four sections, "Indicators Used," Importance," "Findings," and "Direction." Sustainable Indicators: Indicators of sustainability show the relationships among the economy, the environment, and social equity, and demonstrate that any change in one area will affect each of the others.

     

    Category

     

    Indicators

    Agriculture and Forestry

    The three biggest agricultural income products and their acreage were selected for tracking: floriculture and nursery crops; vegetables; and forestry, including Christmas trees.

    Total gross production value and overall acreage devoted to agriculture in the county for the past five years were calculated

    Air Quality

    Measures five air pollutants to see if the Bay Area is compliant with State and National Air Quality Standards: ozone, nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, sulfur oxides, and particulate matter.

    Biodiversity

    Endangered and threatened species

    Child Abuse

    The number of reported cases of child abuse, including physical, mental, and sexual

    Child Care

    Measured are the total number of children in need of child care, the total number of children receiving care outside of their homes from non-family members, the total number of child care slots available, and the cost of child care

    Energy Consumption:

    Methods of electricity generation used; the average annual usage per residential customer

    Homelessness

    The percentage of the total population in 1996 that was served and counted by homelessness agencies. Also measured are the total number of homeless, the number of homeless children, and the number of homeless families. Lastly, the gender, age, ethnicity, duration of homelessness, and frequency of homelessness are shown

    Housing Affordability

    The relationship between the countywide median price of a single-family home and condominium; the countywide average rent for vacant 1-bedroom and 2-bedroom apartments; and the ability to pay annual housing costs are measured.

    Maternal Health

    Prenatal care, low birth weight (under 5.5 lbs.), births to teenage girls, and infant Mortality; Adequate prenatal care was measured by the Kessner Index

    Mortality:

    The mortality rate and causes of death per 100,000 residents

    Per Pupil Spending

    Average expenditures in public schools per annual Average Daily Attendance (ADA) for Kindergarten through 12th grade

    Population

    The July population in each of the last 12 years; the rates of growth; estimated population to the year 2020; the racial/ethnic composition since 1990; and the age structure

    Poverty

    The number of people enrolled in welfare programs

    Public Library Use

    annual expenditures per capita; annual number of hours open to the public; annual materials circulated per capita; and annual number of reference questions asked per capita

    Solid Waste

    the tonnage of solid waste that is disposed into landfills

    Substance Abuse DUI Arrests

    the number of arrests for driving under the influence (DUI) of alcohol or drugs

    Transportation:

    estimated highway vehicle miles traveled (VMT) per year within the county; estimated number of commute trips per day into, out of, and within the county; estimated number of commute trips per day by travel mode; estimated congestion delay on county freeways; annual gasoline consumption; annual bus and train ridership; and level of service (LOS), a rating of congestion, on selected roadway segments.

    Unemployment:

    The average annual unemployment rates over the past decade- all people sixteen years or older who don't have a job, who have made efforts to find employment during the previous four weeks, and who are available for employment. In addition it includes those waiting to return to employment and those starting work within the next 30 days. The number of unemployed is then divided by the number of people in the labor force to yield the unemployment rate.

    Voter Participation

    the percent of the adult population that is registered to vote; the percent of registered voters that actually voted; and the percent of the adult population that actually voted

    Water Consumption

    annual per capita water consumption

    Water Quality Tap Water

    Levels of trihalomethanes (THMs), methy tertiary butyl ether (MTBE), copper, and lead.

     

    Measuring Sustainable Development: Review of Current Practices. Hardi et al. 1997. Occasional Paper Number 17. Industry Canada.

    Partial list of Rudimentary Indicators for Sustainable Development, Canada

     

    Category

     

    Indicators

     

    Ecosystem

    • Temperature (daily and trends over time)
    • Concentration of contaminants in indoor and outdoor air that are common (CO2, NO2 ground level ozone, carbon monoxide) and toxic (dioxins, lead etc)
    • Concentration of contaminants in water (mercury, DDT's, PCBs etc)
    • Concentration of contaminants in the tissue of fish, birds, wildlife and humans
    • Rates of soil erosion
    • Acid deposition
    • Loss of Wildlife habitat
    • The state of biodiversity
    • Genetic diversity within species
    • Species diversity
    • Species health population shifts in wildlife

     

    Interaction

    • Contribution to well being by activity (value added by agriculture, manufacturing, financial services, housework etc.)
    • Resource use (per unit of time or per unit of output
    • Generation of contaminant emissions
    • Heat and waste products capita or per unit of production
    • Loading to air, surface water, ground water or land by activity (by automobiles, pulp and paper manufacturing, energy production etc.)
    • The totals for regions and the nation
    • Proportion of materials recycled
    • Renewable resource harvesting rates
    • Non-renewable resource extraction rates
    • Degree of compliance with laws and regulations

     

    People

    • Infant mortality rates
    • Literacy rates
    • Life expectancy at birth
    • Incidence of disease
    • Employment and unemployment rates
    • Income levels
    • Degree of pride in community and culture
    • Corporate bankruptcies
    • Level of indebtedness (individual, community, nation)
    • Obesity (adults)
    • Malnutrition (children)
    • Caloric intake and the proportion of it acquired from local, Canadian and foreign foods

     

     

    President's Council List of Sustainable Development Indicators, United States.

    The President's Council. 1996. Sustainable America: a New Consensus. Washington, DC: President's Council List on Sustainable Development.

     

     

    Goals

     

    Indicators of Progress

    Health and the Environment

    • Clean air
    • Drinking water
    • Toxic exposure
    • Disease and mortality

    Economic Prosperity

    • Economic performance
    • Employment
    • Poverty
    • Savings and investment rates
    • Natural resources and environmental accounting
    • Productivity

    Equity

    • Income trends
    • Environmental equity
    • Social equity

    Conservation of Nature

    • Ecosystems
    • Habitat loss
    • Threatened and endangered species
    • Nutrients and toxics
    • Exotic species
    • Global environmental change

    Stewardship

    • Materials consumed
    • Waste reduction
    • Energy efficiency
    • Renewable resource use

    Sustainable communities

    • Community economic viability
    • Safe neighbourhoods
    • Public parks
    • Investment into future generations
    • Transportation patterns
    • Community access to information
    • Shelter
    • Metropolitan income patterns
    • Infant mortality

    Civic Engagement

    • Public participation
    • Social capital
    • Citizen participation
    • Collaborations

    Population

    • Population growth
    • Status of women
    • Unintended pregnancies
    • Teen pregnancies
    • Immigration

    International Responsibility

    • International assistance
    • Environmental assistance
    • Assessment of progress
    • Environmental technology exports
    • Research leadership

    Education

    • Information access
    • Curriculum development
    • National standard
    • Community participation
    • National achievement
    • Graduation rates

     

     

    Inter-Agency Working Group on Sustainable Development Indicators:

    Proposed Indicator Definitions.

    Measuring Sustainable Development: Review of Current Practices. Hardi et al. 1997. Occasional Paper Number 17. Industry Canada.

     

    SDI Name

     

    SDI Definition

    Capital assets

    Total value, in dollars, of U.S. tangible reproducible capital, excluding all public infrastructure, as defined in the National Capital Accounts

    Community group participation

    The average number of hours per week per capita devoted to participation in community organizations

    Consumption expenditures per capita

    Total dollar value of goods and services purchased by consumers per year as defined in the National Capital Accounts

    Contaminants in biota

    Chemical contaminants in land, estuarine and marine biota

    Crime rate

    Overall crimes for the U.S.

    Energy consumption per capita

    Total energy consumption divided by total population organized by type of energy source (coal, gas, oil, nuclear, renewable)

    Family function

    Measure of families effectively performing their basic functions. This serves as a place holder until a better, more specific measure gets defined

    Fish catch to growth ratio

    Total fish landings (including by-catch) divided by the fish population growth rate

    Greenhouse climate response index

    Arithmetic average of: 1) percent of US with much above normal min. temp. 2) percent of US with much above normal ppt during the months of Oct. through April; 3) percent of US in extreme or severe drought during the months of May through Sept., and 4) the percent of US with a much greater than normal proportion of ppt derived from extreme one day events (exceeding 2 inches)

    Greenhouse gas emissions

    Emissions of: CO2, CH3, NO2, CFCs and ozone

    Groundwater contamination

    Area of land with contaminated groundwater

    Income distribution

    Distribution of income per capita arranged to show the percentage of the population at various levels of income

    Invasive exotic species

    The total number of invasive species and their distribution in the US

    Investment percentage of GDP

    Investment share of GDP (%), including research, technology development, invention and innovation, as defined in the National Income Accounts. Includes both public and private investment

    Major land use including urban

    The total land area in the US broken down by major estuarine and land ecosystems. Includes both urban and agricultural land

    Materials use per capita

    Total metric tons of materials in use divided by total population organized by type, including recycled

    Outdoor recreation services

    Total number of visitors days per person attributed to outdoor recreation and tourism

    Ozone depleting substances

    Production and consumption of ozone-depleting substances

    People in clean air non-attainment areas

    Number of people living in areas that do not meet air quality standards

    Population health

    A placeholder indicator to measure the status of health in the population

    Receipt of health care

    % of population with adequate access to health care as a function of income level

    Soil types

    Land area organized by soil types

    Species in trouble

    The total number of species in trouble in the US

    Teacher capabilities

    The average capacity or skill level of individual teachers to instruct students

    Test scores by economic group

    Standardized achievement test scores organized by economic group

    Timber harvest to growth ratio

    Timber harvest divided by total timber growth rate per year

    Total managed waste

    Total mass of waste management in man-made facilities in the US organized by type (including nuclear), by site and by hazard level. This does not include waste already released in the environment or in abandoned, uncontrolled sites

    Total population

    Total pop in the US organized by geographic area

    Toxic land area

    Area and percent of land experiencing an accumulation of persistent toxic substances , including superfund and brown field sites

    Water consumption to renewal ratio

    Total water consumed per year divided by the total water resource growth rate per year

    Water quality index

    Index of water quality measuring the appropriate concentrations of selected chemical, physical and sanitary constituents of water at stations

    Work force skill level

    The average level of experience, capability, knowledge and social skills of the individuals in the work force

     

     

    Women's Indicators and Statistics (WISTAT): http://www.un.org/Depts/unsd/gender/wistat/wistat.htm

    Database of statistics and indicators on the advancement of women and the achievement of equality between men and women. Includes some 1500 statistical series on aspects of the economic and social life of women and men in 206 countries. Selected data can be printed or downloaded in various spreadsheet formats. Most topics have data for four periods --- 1970, 1980, 1990 and latest available year. Some have data for only the latest available year and a few have projections up to the year 2010.

    Women's Indicators and Statistics Database Version 4, CD-ROM

     

    Category

     

    Indicator

    POPULATION COMPOSITION AND DISTRIBUTION

    1. Estimated and projected population by age and sex
    2. Total, urban and rural population by sex and latest available year
    3. Foreign-born population by sex and latest available year
    4. Average annual rate of population growth

    LEARNING AND EDUCATION

    1. Illiteracy by sex and age group, for total, urban and rural areas and latest available year
    2. Estimates and projections of adult illiteracy, by sex
    3. Enrolment at first level by sex and latest available year
    4. Enrolment at second level by sex and latest available year
    5. Enrolment at third level by sex and latest available year
    6. Net enrolment ratio by level of education and sex
    7. Gross enrolment ratio by level of education and sex
    8. Third level enrolment by field of study and sex
    9. Third level students per100,000 population by sex
    10. Teachers at first level by sex
    11. Teachers at second level by sex
    12. Teachers at third level by sex
    13. School life expectancy, by sex
    14. Educational attainment of population 25+ by sex, for total, urban and rural areas
    15. Total public expenditure on education as percentage of GNP and all public expenditure
    16. Number and circulation of daily newspapers
    17. Number of radio receivers per 1000 population
    18. Number of television receivers per 1000 population

    ECONOMIC ACTIVITY

    1. Estimated and projected economic activity rate by sex and age group
    2. Population, economically active population and economic activity rate, by sex and age group
    3. Total, economically active and not economically active population by sex, for total, urban and rural
    4. Female economically active population by marital status and age group
    5. Economically active population by status in employment and sex
    6. Economically active population by sex and major occupation group
    7. Economically active population by sex, status in employment and major industry group
    8. Estimated economically active population by sex and branch of economic activity
    9. Unemployment rate by sex
    10. Women's wages in agriculture, in non-agricultural activities and in manufacturing as a percentage of men's wages
    11. Maternity benefits

    HOUSEHOLDS, MARITAL STATUS AND FERTILITY

    1. Population by sex, age group and marital status
    2. Singulate mean age at marriage by sex
    3. Percentage ever married among persons ages 15-19, by sex
    4. Estimated and projected total fertility rate
    5. Estimated age-specific fertility rates
    6. Age-specific fertility rate for total, urban and rural areas
    7. Household headship by sex and age group
    8. Number of households and average household size, total, urban and rural areas
    9. Female population by age and number of children born alive

    HEALTH AND HEALTH SERVICES

    1. Estimated and projected life expectancy at birth, by sex
    2. Life table survival values at selected ages, by sex (per 100,000)
    3. Estimated and projected infant mortality rate (per 1000 live births)
    4. Child mortality rates by sex
    5. Deaths by cause and sex
    6. Percentage of population with safe drinking water, for total, urban and rural areas
    7. Percentage of population with adequate sanitation facilities, for total, urban and rural areas
    8. Child malnutrition indicators by sex
    9. Smoking prevalence among persons15 years of age and over, by sex
    10. Estimated number of people living with HIV/AIDS, numbers of AIDS cases and of AIDS deaths
    11. Reported cumulative AIDS cases and their % distribution by sex and by mode of transmission

    REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH AND REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS

    1. Estimated maternal mortality ratio
    2. Contraceptive prevalence among currently married women of reproductive age, by method used
    3. Contraceptive prevalence among currently married women of reproductive age, by method used and urban/rural residence
    4. Percentage distribution of births by person assisting mother at the time of delivery, for total, urban and rural areas
    5. Percentage of infants breastfed
    6. Percentage of births delivered by C-section
    7. Percentage of women currently married or in union with unmet need for family planning, for total, urban and rural areas
    8. Percentage of women who had given birth by age 20
    9. Percentage of women aged 40-44 who have not had a live birth
    10. Percentage of women requiring more than an hour or two hours travel time to the nearest facility providing family planning services or supplies
    11. Circumstances under which abortion is permitted
    12. Women and men's expressed ideal number of children, for total, urban and rural areas
    13. Estimated percentage of pregnant women with antenatal care, deliveries in health facilities and deliveries attended by skilled personnel

    PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND POLITICAL PARTICIPATION

    1. Years in which women acquired the right to vote and to stand for election
    2. Distribution of seats in parliamentary assemblies by sex
    3. United Nations staff in posts subject to geographical distribution, by nationality and grade, total and female
    4. Professional staff of the organization in the UN common system by grade, total and female
    5. Distribution of ministerial posts by sex and ministry
    6. Date of ratification and entry into force of CEDAW

    VIOLENCE

    1. Prevalence of violence against women by an intimate partner
    2. Deaths from external causes, by sex, age and cause of death

    NATIONAL PRODUCT AND EXPENDITURE

    Total and per capita gross domestic product (GDP) in US dollars

    1. Average annual growth rate of GDP
    2. Percentage distribution of government social security benefit expenditure by branch of social security

    Hart Evironmental Indicators

    http://www.subjectmatters.com/indicators/Indicators/ChecklistItself.html

    "What's a rank?" A rank is a number that is assigned to an indicator by applying the criteria described in the indicator checklist. The higher the number, the better the indicator.

     

    Category

     

    Rank

    INDICATORS

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    ECONOMY

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    ECONOMY CONT'D

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    ECONOMY CONT'D

     

    5

    5

    3

    3

    3

    2

    2

    2

    2

    2

    2

     

     

    6

    4

    4

    4

     

    6

    6

    6

    6

    5

    5

     

    7

    6

    5

    5

    5

    4

    4

    3

    3

    3

    2

    2

    2

    2

     

    9

    7

    7

    7

    6

    6

    6

    4

    3

    2

    2

    2 2

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

     

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7 6

    6

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

    4

    4

    4

    2

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

    1

     

    8

    8

    6

    6

    6

    5

    5

    4

    4

    4

    3

    2

     

    7

    3

    1

     

    2

    1

    1

     

    3

    2

    2

    Business Indicators

    1. Percent of organizations that have adopted sustainable development goals
    2. Business participation in school and civic events
    3. Office vacancy rate
    4. Percent of companies developing new products or services
    5. State rank in telecommunications technology
    6. New business starts
    7. Number of environmental services, products and technologies exported
    8. Percent of GDP from secondary production and business services
    9. Number of building permits issued
    10. Number of business establishments
    11. Government subsidies as percent of gross income

    Manufacturing productivity

    Children Indicators

    1. Children living in poverty
    2. Students eligible for free or reduced price lunch
    3. Children receiving AFDC
    4. AFDC recipients on more than 24 consecutive months

    Diversity Indicators

    1. Unemployment rate by ethnicity
    2. Discrimination in the workplace
    3. Occupational distribution of women and minorities
    4. Number of commercial crop varieties
    5. Employment by sector
    6. Employment by top five employers

    Employment Indicators

    1. Average age of commercial fish harvesters
    2. Percent of residents who want to work full time who actually work full time
    3. Long-term unemployment
    4. Manufacturing wage and salary jobs as a percent of total jobs
    5. Unemployment rate
    6. Professional, technical and managerial occupations as percent of total
    7. Agricultural employment
    8. Employment rate
    9. Number of green jobs
    10. Total wage and salary jobs per employed resident
    11. Net job growth
    12. Job growth among new businesses
    13. Total wage and salary jobs
    14. Number of jobs in value-added manufacturing

    Finance Indicators

    1. Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare
    2. Number and value of business loans in low income area
    3. Percent of products and services where price reflects life-cycle cost
    4. Energy and machinery expenses as percent of gross farm income
    5. Per capita debt
    6. GDP per capita adjusted for natural resource depletion
    7. Environmentally adjusted Net Domestic Product
    8. Percent of GDP spent on research and development
    9. Market value of environmental permits traded or sold
    10. Growth in value added in forest products industry (paper and lumber)
    11. Agriculture value added as a percent of gross sales
    12. Value of business personal property per worker
    13. Annual capital dollars invested in municpal infrastructure
    14. Per capita gross state product as percent of US GNP
    15. Value of industrial and commercial property
    16. Total dollars and dollars per capita deposited in local banks annually
    17. Value of residential and business properties
    18. Value of building permits
    19. Assessed value of real estate per capita, inflation adjusted
    20. Value of goods exported internationally
    21. Gross State Product rate of increase vs. N.E. GSP rate of increase

    Income Indicators

    1. Distribution of wealth
    2. Percent of jobs that pay a liveable wage for a family of two
    3. Corporate executive to production worker wages (ratio)
    4. Percent of jobs that did not pay a self-sufficiency wage
    5. Income distribution
    6. Percent of disposable personal income that is being saved
    7. Average income of the bottom and top 20 percent
    8. Hours of labor required to meet basic needs
    9. Population areas with poverty more than 1.5 times state rate
    10. People living below the poverty line
    11. Manufacturing wage and salary earnings as a percent of total income
    12. Food stamp recipients
    13. Length of time on welfare
    14. Number or percent of residents receiving welfare assistance
    15. Income disparity among counties
    16. Households with incomes more than 200 percent above poverty line
    17. Population in areas with per capita income less than 70 percent of US
    18. Effective buying income per capita
    19. Personal income per capita
    20. Average earnings per job
    21. Median family income as percent of US median
    22. Cost of living index
    23. Per capita income as percent of state average
    24. Per capita income in non metropolitan areas

    Resource Use Indicators

    1. Sales of locally produced food at farmers market
    2. Percent of harvested forest successfully restocked
    3. Affordable warmth (average energy efficiency rating of homes)
    4. Annual acreage in field crops
    5. Feed production and use balance
    6. Industrial use of toxic chemicals
    7. Farm acreage
    8. Volume of large sawtimber trees
    9. Fish landings by weight
    10. Key natural resource harvests
    11. Values of key natural resources
    12. Cost of 1,000 kWh of electricity

    Sales Indicators

    1. Dollars spent in locally-owned businesses
    2. Retail sales per capita
    3. Retail sales as a percent of personal income

    Tourism Indicators

    1. Value added in hotel and lodging industry
    2. Tourism/bed-tax revenues
    3. Employment in hotel and lodging industry

    Transportation Indicators

    1. Percent of all manufacturing freight transported by rail, air, or water
    2. Containers transported through seaport (TEU's)
    3. Freight shipping availability in nonmetro areas

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    EDUCATION

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    EDUCATION CONT'D

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    6

    4

    4

    4

    3

     

    5

    5

    4

     

    8

     

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

    4

    3

     

    1

     

    8

    6

    3

    2

    2

     

    6

    5

    5

     

    5

    4

    4

    2

     

    7

    6

    6

    6

    5

     

    6

    5

     

    5

    4

    4

    4

    4

     

     

    Adult Indicators

    1. Adult education enrollment
    2. Percentage of persons retrainable with existing funds
    3. Percentage of population with high school diploma
    4. Percentage of adults with associate's, bachelor's or graduate degree
    5. Waiting time for adult ESL courses

    Children Indicators

    1. Number of children on subsidized childcare waiting list
    2. Number of child care spaces needed in each age group
    3. Nursery education (number of children attending pre-school)

    Literacy Indicators

    1. Literacy rate

    Post-secondary Indicators

    1. Students entering postsecondary education
    2. Rate of college graduation (five year rate)
    3. Technical school graduates employed in field
    4. Tuition net cost as percent of disposable income
    5. Degrees awarded from county universities and community colleges
    6. High school graduates pursuing advanced training
    7. Number of pupils completing college entrance requirement

    Schools Indicators

    1. Operating expenditure per student

    Skills Indicators

    1. Numeracy
    2. High school graduates needing remediation in community colleges or state univ.
    3. Achievement Test Scores
    4. Percent of districts with mean test scores equal/above state average
    5. Percent of districts with graduation rate above state average

    Sustainability Indicators

    1. Frequency of sustainable development in K-12 curricula
    2. Sustainable development literacy of the public
    3. Number of schools in sustainable school program

    Teacher Indicators

    1. Ethnic diversity of teaching staff
    2. Student/teacher ratio
    3. Education level of faculty
    4. Average teacher salary

    Training Indicators

    1. Employer-sponsored training for front-line employees
    2. Number of residents in job training programs
    3. Number of residents in vocational programs
    4. Number of students in job prep programs
    5. Percent of post-secondary graduates finding employment in their field

    Volunteers Indicators

    1. Volunteer involvement in schools
    2. Number of community volunteer programs to support schools

    Youth Indicators

    1. High school graduation rates
    2. Students failing 1st grade
    3. Television and video use by 6th graders
    4. School dropout rate
    5. Schools with 12th grade dropout rate over 10 percent

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    ENVIRONMENT

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    ENVIRONMENT CONT'D

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    ENVIRONMENT CONT'D

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    9

    9

    8

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    6

    6

    6

    6

    5

    3

     

    5

    5

    5

    3

     

     

    8

    8

    7

    7

    6

    6

    6

    5

    3

     

    8

    8

    8

    7

    6

    6

     

    7

    7

    5

     

    9

    7

    5

    3

     

    5

    4

     

    11

    10

    10

    10

    10

    10

    10

    9

    9

    9

    9

    9

    8

    8

    8

    8

    8

    8

    8

    8

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    6

    6

    6

    6

    4

     

    8

    8

    6

    4

     

    9

    8

    7

    7

    7

    6

    6

    6

    6

    6

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

    3

     

    9

    6

     

    Air Indicators

    1. CO2 emissions from transportation
    2. CO2 emissions by source
    3. CO2 emissions relative to 1990 levels
    4. Number of days air pollutants exceed healthful levels
    5. Air quality:CO, SO2, SPM, and O3 measurements
    6. Emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases
    7. Air pollutants from stationary sources
    8. Exposure to substandard ambient air quality
    9. Days per year that air quality standards are met
    10. Production of acid-forming emissions
    11. Ratio of SO2 and smoke levels to EC limits
    12. Air quality index
    13. Particulate matter in air
    14. Number of complaints about air quality per year

    Awareness Indicators

    1. Number of environmental education programs for community
    2. Number of environmental education programs at elementary schools
    3. Students passing environmental education test
    4. Number participating in Environmental Farm Plan Program

     

    Biodiversity Indicators

    1. Biodiversity - amphibian
    2. Biodiversity - plant
    3. Song bird diversity or population
    4. Number of species at risk
    5. Proportion of species approaching target population size
    6. Acres of occupied grizzly habitat
    7. Tailed frog population
    8. Stream miles opened for migratory fish
    9. Population of endemic species for which the region has key custodial role

    Fish Indicators

    1. Fish species with consumption restricted
    2. Commercial salmon catch in watershed
    3. Overfished fisheries compared to fisheries not overfished
    4. Wild salmon returning to spawn
    5. Acres of closed shellfish beds
    6. Oyster Condition Index

    Global Indicators

    1. Output to sink / capacity of sink to absorb or assimilate
    2. CO2 emission per capita, relative to fair earth share
    3. Greenhouse gas emissions measured in metric tons of carbon equivalents

    Groundwater Indicators

    1. Water level in aquifer wells
    2. Monitored wells showing groundwater contamination
    3. Groundwater quality index
    4. New septic tank permits

    Human Indicators

    1. Indoor air quality
    2. Noise complaints to local authorities

    Land Use Indicators

    1. Land use patterns
    2. Agricultural land loss / total arable land
    3. Open land lost to development in square km
    4. Total area in significant land-use categories
    5. Rate of change of wilderness area
    6. Number of acres of major terrestrial ecosystems
    7. Acres of cropland that have been converted to developed land
    8. Impervious surfaces
    9. Acreage of land used for streets
    10. Number of biogeographical regions with adequate protected areas
    11. Acres under integrated pest management
    12. Percent of new residential lots within 1/4 mile of services
    13. Land area in parks and wildlife refuges
    14. Percent of significant natural areas protected
    15. Forest land acres
    16. Loss of primary forests / total primary forests remaining
    17. Number of acres of public open space
    18. Area used for organic agriculture / area used for chemical intensive agriculture
    19. Proportion of original agricultural land reserve (ALR) still designated ALR
    20. Trees lost and gained through multi-family development
    21. Number of trees in urban 'forest'
    22. Open space in urban villages
    23. Parks and playgrounds as percent of urban area
    24. Land parcels greater than 80 acres, and greater than 160 acres
    25. Privately owned acres placed under conservation easement
    26. Number of trees on public property
    27. Area of lands under formal agreement for wildlife habitat
    28. Index of land naturalness
    29. Acres of environmentally sensitive areas
    30. Length of heritage rivers

    Soil Indicators

    1. Soil erosion per acre of cropland
    2. Average soil erosion on cultivated cropland as a proportion of tolerable rate
    3. Area of land affected by soil erosion and salinity
    4. Soil organic matter content

    Surface Water Indicators

    1. Percentage of estuarine areas not suitable for shellfish harvesting
    2. Quality of river water entering country / quality leaving country
    3. Number of days all beaches are open for swimmming
    4. Percent of streams you can drink from
    5. Fishable and swimmable river miles and lake acres
    6. Fecal coliform count in surface water
    7. Miles of rivers not suitable for fishing due to dioxin
    8. Percentage area of lakes fully suitable for swimming
    9. Index of watershed naturalness
    10. Bernie Fowler's Sneaker Index - water clarity
    11. Amount of road salt used on rural regional roads
    12. Compliance with dissolved oxygen standards
    13. River compliance with metals water standards
    14. Bay grasses recovering, in acres
    15. Phosphorus concentration in county streams
    16. Biological oxygen demand of county streams

    Wetlands Indicators

    1. Acres of natural and restored wetlands
    2. Size and distribution of significant wetlands

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    GOVERNMENT

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    GOVERNMENT CONT'D

     

    7

    7

    7

     

    3

    3

    2

    2

    2

     

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

    4

    4

    4

    3

     

    6

     

    2

     

    5

    1

     

    4

    Diversity Indicators

    1. Racial and ethnic representation in Legislature
    2. Racial/gender diversity of city council members
    3. Women who are legislators or officers

    Effectiveness Indicators

    1. Taxpayer satisfaction with services
    2. Citizen satisfaction with state government services
    3. Number of stated goals and established measures for local or state budget
    4. Percent who trust local government vs federal government
    5. Percent who believe that most or all of every tax dollar paid is wasted by gov

    Participation Indicators

    1. Campaign contributions from small contributers
    2. Community representation on health boards
    3. Number of people who can name two city council members
    4. Visibility of local issues
    5. Voting rate of registered voters
    6. Households participating in residents or ratepayer associations
    7. Voter participation in primary elections
    8. Voter turnout for municipal elections
    9. Percent of eligible voters registered

    Regulations Indicators

    1. Percent of sustainable development compatible legislation

    Services Indicators

    1. City human services expenditures per capita

    Taxes Indicators

    1. Fiscal stability and balanced revenue
    2. State and local tax burden

    Volunteerism Indicators

    1. Citizen volunteer advisors to gov't who felt their contributions were respected

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    HEALTH

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    HEALTH CONT'D

     

    6

    4

     

    6

    3

     

     

    4

    2

    1

     

    4

    4

    4

    4

    3

    3

    3

    3

    3

    3

     

    6

    5

    3

    3

    3

    3

    3

    3

    3

     

    9

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

     

    5

    5

    5

     

    3

     

    7

    4

    Access to Care Indicators

    1. Emergency room use for nonemergency purposes
    2. Percentage of people identifying obstacles to obtaining health care

    Children Indicators

    1. Asthma hospitalization rate for children
    2. Infant mortality

     

    Cost Indicators

    1. Health care as percent of income
    2. Health care cost relative to total state/local expenditure
    3. Total health care expenditures

    Disease Indicators

    1. Death from stroke per 100,000 population
    2. Deaths from lung cancer per 100,000 population
    3. Deaths from stress and immune system failures
    4. Health limitations on school/work/activity
    5. Deaths from heart disease per 100,000 population
    6. Deaths from all cancers per 100,000 population
    7. Syphilis cases per 100,000
    8. AIDS cases per 100,000
    9. Breast cancer deaths per 100,000 women
    10. Tuberculosis cases reported/100,000 population

    Drug Use Indicators

    1. Density of alcohol outlets in certain areas
    2. Number of alcohol outlets per capita
    3. Percent of population who smoke
    4. Alcohol and drug use reported by youths
    5. Cigarette use by youth at grades 5, 7, 9, 12
    6. Cocaine use by youth at grades 5, 7, 9, 12
    7. Death rate per 100,000 related to tobacco and alcohol
    8. Percent of population who use illicit drugs
    9. Police incidents related to alcohol & other drugs

    Fitness Indicators

    1. Healthy diets for children
    2. Life expectancy
    3. Perceived quality of life
    4. Percent of population who are physically active
    5. Student fitness test scores
    6. Percent of people who eat 5 or more servings of fruits and vegetables per day

    Insurance Indicators

    1. Percent of population covered by health insurance
    2. Number of households with at least 1 uninsured member
    3. Number of children without health insurance

    Mortality Indicators

    1. Deaths per 100,000 population ages 0-64

    Pregnancy/Birth Indicators

    1. Percent of women receiving adequate prenatal care
    2. Low birthweight infants

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    HOUSING

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    8

    7

    7

    6

    5

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

    4

    3

    3

    3

    2

    2

     

    9

    5

    5

    5

     

    7

    7

    6

    6

    6

    5

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

    Availability Indicators

    1. House price to income ratio
    2. Number of homeless people
    3. Distribution of affordable housing throughout city
    4. Homeownership rate
    5. Share of new housing units going into incorporated parts of county
    6. Waiting time for subsidized housing
    7. Annual applicants for affordable housing
    8. Single family housing growth compared to population growth
    9. Number of people using homeless shelters
    10. Yearly percentage increase in number of dwelling units
    11. Number of houses versus population
    12. Average annual vacancy rate
    13. New multi-family units as percent of total new residential units
    14. Number of rehabilitated affordable housing units
    15. New privately-owned housing units
    16. New housing starts

    Condition Indicators

    1. Floor area per person in housing
    2. Low-income housing with severe physical problem
    3. Percent of dwellings in need of major repair
    4. Housing that is inadequate, overcrowded, or costs over 30% of income

    Cost Indicators

    1. Affordability of single family home
    2. Renters who cannot afford to live in the city
    3. Low-income renters paying more than 30 percent of income on rent
    4. Home ownership rate
    5. Number of new homes that are energy-efficient
    6. Housing affordability ratio - rent prices
    7. Median family income as percent of median single family house price
    8. Median family income as percent of average rent on two-bedroom apartment
    9. Median family income as percent of annual single family house mortgage payment
    10. Percent of households able to afford buying median single family house
    11. Median family income as a percent of average property tax

     

     

    POPULATION

     

     

     

    POPULATION CONT'D

     

     

    8

    5

     

    8

    6

     

    2

    Growth Indicators

    1. Population growth
    2. Total population

    Migration Indicators

    1. Population density
    2. Net migration gain and loss

    Structure Indicators

    1. Age trends in population

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    PUBLIC SAFETY

     

     

    4

    4

    3

    3

     

    5

    5

    4

    4

    4

    2

    2

    3

     

    4

    3

     

    5

    4

    4

    3

    3

    3

    Accidents Indicators

    1. Percent traffic injuries to cylists/pedestrians
    2. Safety for pedestrians and pedal cyclists
    3. Deaths from all accidents per 100,000 population
    4. Traffic accident deaths per capita

    Crime Indicators

    1. Crime victims as percent of population
    2. People feeling safe walking alone at night
    3. Crime rate
    4. Property crimes
    5. Percentage who decreased park use due to fear
    6. Number of Neighborhood Watch groups
    7. Number of sworn police officers per 1,000 people
    8. Juvenile crime rate

    Services Indicators

    1. Average rescue call response time
    2. Emergency calls per capita

    Violence Indicators

    1. Number of violent crimes on public transit
    2. Violent crime rate
    3. Domestic assault reported per 100,000 population
    4. Homicide rate per 100,000
    5. Rapes reported per 10,000 population
    6. Calls to Rape Crisis Centre

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    RECREATION

     

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

    4

     

    3

    2

    2

    1

     

    8

    6

    6

    6

    5

     

    3

    3

    Accessibility Indicators

    1. Number of people using recreation facilities each month
    2. Attendance at Mt. Ranier per mile of trail
    3. Opportunities to participate in art (theater, etc)
    4. Number of people served by museums and arts events
    5. Community centers per person
    6. Event/days of bookings at city facilities

    Cost Indicators

    1. City parks/rec expenditures per capita
    2. City financial support of arts organizations per capita
    3. Funding amounts and sources for recreation facilities
    4. Major arts expenditures

    Land Use Indicators

    1. Acres of park lands per person
    2. Recreational trail miles
    3. Public access sites on lakes and rivers
    4. Acres of conservation land intended for public use
    5. Number and size of recreational, cultural and spiritual sites

    Participation Indicators

    1. Attendance at major arts events or cultural facilities
    2. Public participation in the arts

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    RESOURCE USE

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    RESOURCE USE CONT'D

     

    8

    8

    8

    8

    8

    8

    8

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    7

    5

    4

    4

    1

     

    7

    7

    7

    6

    6

    6

    6

    6

    6

    6

    6

    5

    5

    5

     

    8

    8

    7

    7

     

    8

    8

    6

    4

     

    8

     

    8

    8

    6

    3

    1

     

    7

    2

    1

     

    9

    9

    9

    9

    9

    9

    9

    9

    9

    Energy Indicators

    1. Average annual residential electricity consumption
    2. Total energy consumption
    3. Electricity consumption from nonrenewables
    4. Renewable energy use
    5. Residential natural gas therms consumed per household
    6. Proportion of energy from fossil and non-fossil fuel sources
    7. Percent of energy supplied from renewable sources within the state
    8. Gasoline consumption per capita
    9. Nonrenewable energy use
    10. Commerical energy consumption per year
    11. Energy use (non mobile sources
    12. Electricity consumption
    13. Electricity and natural gas use per person per year
    14. Heat loss of residential buildings
    15. Commercial/industrial natural gas therms consumed per total employment
    16. Fuel consumption
    17. Households per residential MWH consumed
    18. Per capita consumption of fossil fuel by motor vehicle transport
    19. Total employment per industrial and commercial MWH consumed
    20. Per capita gasoline sales
    21. Number of counties with access to all major energy sources
    22. Cost of energy

    Hazardous Material

    1. Manufacturing workers per pound of toxic chemicals released into the air
    2. Manufacturing workers per pound of toxic chemicals released into the water
    3. Quantity of spent nuclear fuel generated each year
    4. Purchase of ozone depleting substances
    5. Toxic chemicals released or transferred
    6. Total area of contaminated sites
    7. Consumption of pesticides
    8. Hazardous waste generated
    9. Hazardous waste generated by city operations
    10. Pesticide useage
    11. Number of pounds of toxic materials released into the environment
    12. Number of underground storage tanks requiring cleanup
    13. Compliance with UST standards for all underground storage tanks
    14. City purchases of hazardous materials

    Materials Indicators

    1. Accumulated depreciation of natural resources
    2. Materials consumption per capita
    3. Renewable resources used/total natural resources used
    4. Resource (material and energy) throughput/ end use output

    Recycling Indicators

    1. Percentage of solid waste recycled
    2. Percent of recyclable products actually recycled
    3. Average post-consumer recycled content of city office paper purchases
    4. Number of people involved in recycling initiative

    Renewable Indicators

    1. The growth rate of timber compared to the rate of harvest

    Solid Waste Indicators

    1. Solid waste generation
    2. Space used at landfill sites annually
    3. Percent reduction in landfilled solid waste volumes
    4. Highway litter - bags collected per mile
    5. Average monthly residential solid waste charge

    Waste Water Indicators

    1. Percent reduction in wastewater flows
    2. Gallons of waste water processed as percent of permitted capacity
    3. Real household monthly service charge for waste water treatment

    Water Indicators

    1. Water use per capita
    2. Residential water consumption
    3. Commerical water consumption
    4. Gallons of water used daily per person
    5. Water resource depletion rates
    6. Reduce potable water use 20 percent
    7. Total water consumption
    8. Water demand and supply
    9. Water consumption versus total annual precipitation

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    SOCIETY

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    SOCIETY CONT'D

     

    5

    3

     

    7

    5

    5

    5

    4

    3

    2

     

    8

    7

    5

    4

    3

    3

    3

    3

     

    3

     

    4

    3

     

    6

    6

     

    3

    3

     

    5

    4

    4

    4

    5

    5

    4

    3

    Abuse Indicators

    1. Abuse and neglect of children
    2. Number of children receiving protective services for abuse/neglect

    Children Indicators

    1. Childcare arrangement satisfaction
    2. Children involved in divorce per 1,000 children
    3. Divorces involving children
    4. Students who move more than once a year
    5. Percent of family groups with only one parent living with a child under age 18
    6. Children in foster care per 1,000 children
    7. Runaways per 1,000 children

    Connectedness Indicators

    1. Number of community gardens
    2. Percent of people who say they have enough
    3. Average distance between residences of extended family members
    4. Citizen participation in community projects
    5. Neighborliness
    6. People feeling they can rely on others in community for help
    7. Percent who say most people can be trusted
    8. Neighborhood livability as rated by residents

    Culture Indicators

    1. Number of arts events/performances at public sites

    Diversity Indicators

    1. Discrimination complaints filed
    2. Racism perception

    Literacy Indicators

    1. Public library items circulated per person
    2. Public library materials per capita

    Mental Health Indicators

    1. Suicide attempts of 12th grade students
    2. Suicide rate per 100,000

    Pregnancy/Birth Indicators

    1. Births to females under 18 per 1,000 live births
    2. Births to mothers without 12 years of education
    3. Births to unwed mothers
    4. Substance-exposed newborns per 1,000 live births

    Volunteerism Indicators

    1. Volunteer rate
    2. Percent of people who volunteer at least 50 hours per year
    3. Youth involvement in community service
    4. Charitable contributions

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    TRANSPORTATION

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    2

    2

     

    7

    6

    6

    4

     

    7

    5

    5

    5

    5

    5

    5

    4

     

    3

    3

    3

    1

     

    5

    5

    4

    4

    4

    3

    3

    3

    2

    1

    1

     

    7

    7

    7

    6

    6

    5

    5

    4

    3

    Air Indicators

    1. Destinations with direct flights in/out of airport
    2. Weekday commercial flights in/out of airport

    Alternate Indicators

    1. Pedestrian friendly streets
    2. Ratio of bike paths to streets
    3. Percent of street miles designated bike route miles
    4. Total length of bicycle routes

    Commute Indicators

    1. Percent of population taking each mode of transportation to work
    2. Automobile occupancy rate
    3. Average vehicle ridership for companies with 50+ employees
    4. Commuters driving alone
    5. Average commuting distance to work
    6. People with commute time 25 minutes or less
    7. Percent of people who live and work in city
    8. Number of businesses cooperating with Park/Ride program

    Infrastructure Indicators

    1. Waiting time at intersections with traffic signals
    2. Condition of roads
    3. Condition of bridges
    4. Public expenditure on private transportation

    Public Transit Indicators

    1. Ridership on fixed routes transit buses
    2. Percentage of people choosing transit over car
    3. Annual transit ridership per capita
    4. Miles of fixed-route bus service
    5. Number of minutes between buses on scheduled routes
    6. Percent who perceive public transit unsafe
    7. Number of transit-rider trips per capita
    8. Percent of transit service miles to total street miles
    9. Transit revenues per transit-rider trip, inflation adjusted
    10. Cost per transit-rider trip, inflation adjusted
    11. Public expenditure on public transit

    Vehicle Indicators

    1. Vehicle miles traveled
    2. Vehicles per household
    3. Population versus vehicle miles traveled
    4. Percent of city fleet converted to reduced emission fuels
    5. Ratio of fuel-efficient/fuel-inefficient vehicles
    6. Modal split in vehicle type
    7. Number of persons per registered passenger car
    8. Vehicles entering central area by mode
    9. Motor vehicle registration

     

     

    Indicators of Sustainability: Interim Report. The Thomas Jefferson Sustainability Council.

    http://www.monticello.avenue.gen.va.usGov/TJPDC

    This interim report constitutes the region's first comprehensive set of indicators.

     

    Goals

     

    Objectives & Indicators

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Human Population

    1. To maintain a human population size that does not reduce the sustainability of the region
      • Size of the population
      • Rate of annual growth and a projected time line for doubling
      • Proportion of annual change caused by:
      1. The difference between in-migration and out-migration
      2. The difference between births and deaths
    1. To maintain a human population distribution that does not reduce the sustainability of the region
      • Population density by land use classification
      • Proportion of new residents moving into each land use classification
      • Distribution among the constituent localities in terms of residential, commercial, and industrial development
    1. To maintain a human population composition that does not reduce the sustainability of the region

    Distribution according to:

      • Age
      • Race/Ethnic diversity
      • Income/wealth
      • Education
      • Employment status
    1. To have fair and effective policy mechanisms to manage these population dynamics
      • Degree to which each locality's Comprehensive Plan articulates sustainable population goals, and proposes mechanisms (which function directly or indirectly) to achieve the desired population size, distribution and composition
      • Resident's understanding of population dynamics and impacts
      • Individual access to fertility management information and services (measured as proportion of unplanned pregnancies to planned pregnancies)

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Human Basic Needs

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Human Basic Needs CONT'D

    1. Every member of the community can obtain adequate daily nutrition
      • Number of people eligible to receive Meals on Wheels, Food Bank, School Lunch programs etc.
      • Percent of eligible people not served by Meals on Wheels, Food Bank, School Lunch programs etc.
    1. Every member of the community can obtain adequate, affordable clothing
      • Number of non-commercial programs (Salvation Army, etc) that provide low-priced clothing to the general population.
      • Amount and location of clothing in non-commercial programs available to the general public
    1. Every member of the community can obtain affordable, safe, adequate housing
      • Number of people on waiting lists for housing
      • Percent of people on waiting lists for housing
      • Number of houses with substandard plumbing
    1. Every member of the community can achieve optimal health
      • Infant mortality rate by race, income and age of mother
      • Number and percent of the community that has access to comprehensive medical care, including dental and preventative care
      • Percent of residents who have access to primary care physician (by race, income, age and other factors)
      • Percent of pregnant women receiving prenatal care, in each trimester
      • Number of people with and without health insurance (including dental and mental health)
      • Number and percent of employers who offer wellness benefits which include health insurance, health education, access to exercise facilities, counseling, dental, time off for maternity/paternity benefits
      • Number and percentage of partnerships between public school health professionals and public school educational professionals
      • Number and percent of emergency room trauma visits, hospitalizations and deaths due to malnutrition, exposure, lack of immunizations, inadequate medical care, environmental and occupational hazards, substance abuse, physical abuse, violence and neglect
      • Percent of population age 70 and above and/or disabled who are living in "non-institutionalized" (refers to seniors a living at home, in naturally occurring retirement communities etc)
    1. Every member of the community can obtain an education consistent with their needs, wants and abilities, to engage them to function as effective members of society
      • Percent of high school graduates going on to post-secondary training
      • Percent of second grade students able to read at their grade level
      • Percent of eligible children participating in formal K-12 education (includes home, private and public) at every level
    1. Provide an education and enforcement programs to create and maintain communities that are safe and secure
      • Part I Crime Index
    1. Every member of the community has access to transportation that is affordable and adequate to meet their basic needs for access to employment, education, health care, and shopping
      • Time and type of commute required to reach essential services such as employment, education, health care and nutrition
    1. Every member of the community who so desires can obtain work that provides just compensation, employment, mobility, and fulfillment. Provide training and support especially for those with the least access to employment.
      • Number and distribution of employment openings correlated with trends in the region's population
      • Number and percent of unemployed involved in training programs
      • Unemployment rate of locality over extended period of time compared to other localities.
      • Number of jobs which provide high hourly wage vs. number of jobs which provide low hourly wage
      • Number of jobs which provide high salary vs. number of jobs which provide low salary

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Economic Development

    1. Understanding the relationship between industrial economy and the larger natural system of energy use and resource exchange:
      • Median "income" per capita calculated as:
      1. the region's value calculated according tot he UN Standardized System of National Accounts (SNA)
      2. value of volunteer labour for which others are paid
      3. change in police costs compared to base year
      4. pollution costs
      • Median "Economic Wealth" per capita calculated as:
      1. SNA for Produced Assets
      2. SNA for Natural Assets
      3. Capitalized value of "income" (proxy Human Capital)
      4. Capitalized value of charitable contributions
      5. Change in capitalized value of payments for liability insurance as compared to base year
      6. Net financial assets held by residents of the region
    1. To encourage strong, flexible, and durable local markets for locally produced goods and services:
      • Number of local start-ups/ failures divided by the total number of local businesses
      • Dollar value of locally produced goods and services purchased in the region per annum
    1. Establish and maintain a diverse mix of small and large scale businesses and industries that operate sustainably:
      • Percent of total employment in large and small scale categories
    1. To achieve a current flow of savings within the region that will lead to sustainable economic future.
      • Total savings
      • Savings/income

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Transportation

    1. Construct a network of bicycle and pedestrian facilities within urban areas in accordance with the localities' Bicycle Plans:
      • Linear miles of facilities constructed especially for pedestrian and bicycle use
    1. Connect urban areas of the cities and counties with bikeways and walkways:
      • Linear miles of facilities constructed especially for pedestrian and bicycle use
    1. Reduce automobile and truck traffic volume and speed in residential areas for the safety of children bicycling and playing in these areas:
      • Linear miles of traffic calmed roads.
    1. Reduce single occupancy automobile trips within the region by developing attractive and economical transit mass alternatives:
      • Auto trips per capita per day
      • Number and percentage of passenger movement within the region carried by rail, bus, and automobile
    1. Reduce single-occupancy automobile trips into and out of the region by developing attractive and economical transit alternatives:
      • Auto trips per capita per day
      • Number and percentage of passenger movement into and out of the region carried by rail, bus, and automobile
    1. Increase tonnage loads for long-haul alternative freight service into and out of the region:
      • Number of tons and percentage of freight movement into and out of the region carried by rail, air, and auto.
    1. Measure costs of traffic congestion to initiate planning for transit systems
      • Automobile and Rail and Bus travel time for various main routes
    1. Measure percentage of local/state/federal transportation funding spent on transit systems:
      • Amount and percentage of money to total for each transportation mode

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Land Development

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    1. Maximize the use and re-use of developed land by clustering the integration to the fullest extent practical business, industry, housing, recreation and green space:
      • Percent of development and building permits in established centres versus rural land
      • Ratio of employees that walk or bike to work versus the number that drive in single occupancy vehicles
      • Number of jurisdictions that incorporate principles and goals of sustainability into comprehensive plan and zoning regulations
    1. Design current development in such a way as to preserve as many options as possible for the use and reuse of developed land, and for the interconnection of the site and adjoining land in the future:
      • Number of miles of bikeway/walkway/low-speed road connections between neighbourhoods, schools and services
    1. Define and incorporate the concept of appropriate scale in all development and land-use decisions:
      • Number of miles of bikeway/walkway/low-speed road connections between neighbourhoods, schools and services
      • Average width of neighbourhood streets
    1. Develop alternative transportation systems which are friendlier, easy to use, convenient, economical, gets you where you want to go, safe, non-polluting and quick:
      • Number and percent of employees that use alternatives to the single occupancy vehicle.
    1. Use renewable energy sources, resource efficient principle of design and construction, and sustainably produced materials in all new structures and encourage the conversion from less efficient structures whenever possible:
      • Lbs. of locally generated construction material
      • Percent of energy consumed that is produced by renewable resources
      • Percent of new and existing buildings certified by sustainable building standards
    1. Encourage the use of information technology to decrease the use of automobiles and to make information more readily available:
      • Percent of employees who telecommute
      • Number of public terminals with access to the Internet in the region, per thousand people.

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Waste

    1. Recycle useable materials:
      • Number of lbs. of solid waste land-filled per capita per year
      • Number of lbs. of usable material entering landfills
      • Number of lbs. of manure compost generated in the region
    1. Minimize the use of unsafe disposal of hazardous material:
      • Number of lbs. of hazardous waste collected for disposal at designated sites
      • Number of lbs. of man-made, toxic, non-biodegradable compounds used or produced in the region
    1. Individuals have a personal responsibility to waste:
      • Number of tickets issued for littering each year
      • Percentage or number of individuals participating in waste reduction efforts
    1. Work independently and in partnership to reduce waste:
      • Number of businesses involved in recycling efforts
      • Using recycled material to produce and end product
      • Number of businesses that convert recyclable to raw materials
      • Number of businesses that are members of the RWSA Business Alliance (?)
      • Number of businesses that meet ISO 14001 standard (requires environmental quality management systems, environmental audits, environmental performance evaluations, product lifecycle assessments and product labeling) in the region
    1. The general population understands and practices the six steps to waste reduction: rethink, reduce, reuse, buy recyclables, recycle, material exchange:
      • Number of people who use cloth bags to grocery shop
    1. Use water efficiently:
      • Per capita water use
      • Gallons of water recycled in manufacturing processes in the region
      • Annually revised estimate of expected "lifetime" of the water supply based on usage trends.

    SOCIAL RESOURCES

    Values/Ethics

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Community Awareness

     

     

     

     

     

    Interdependence/ Balance

     

     

     

     

     

     

    SOCIAL RESOURCES contd

    Interdependence/ Balance CONT'D

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Government

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    1. Create conditions for the fair balance of wealth, power and privilege:
      • Gap between the incomes of population in the top and bottom quartile
      • Measure of wealth, race, gender and residence of elected and appointed members of boards of commissions, relative to the distribution of the same in the population as a whole.
    1. Foster the use of conflict resolution tools in public and private disputes:
      • Number of conflicts mediated in a particular area, i.e. divorce mediation, indigent legal services.
    1. Create conditions in which institutions are encouraged to evaluate the ethical implications of their behavior.
      • Number of institutions with an adopted code of ethics.
    1. Encourage education and media coverage on sustainability, with particular emphasis on what is happening in our region and in our daily lives:
      • Number of sustainability-focussed courses and activities in public, private and post-secondary schools
      • Number of sustainability-related articles in region's news media coverage
      • Number of sustainability-related educational/ consciousness-raising activities offered each year for elected and appointed officials; numbers participating
    1. Improve urban and rural areas' economic interdependence:
      • Percent of rural local ag/forestry products sold in and used as productive inputs in local urban area.
      • Percent of urban residents employed in rural ag/forestry pursuits
      • Percent of urban-created products/services sold in rural areas
      • Membership in regional economic partnerships
      • Number of taxes or fees that meet these criteria:
      • High rate for non-agricultural buildings in rural areas and for land in urban areas
      • Low rate for land in rural areas and for buildings in urban areas
      • Extent to which infrastructure is extended, year by year, into rural areas, measured by
      • miles of new and newly paved roads, sewer and water
    1. Encourage a healthy environmental linkage of urban and rural areas:
      • High population density in urban areas; low population density in rural areas ---- measured by dwelling unit/acre in top and bottom quartile of development
      • Transferable Development Rights availability and usage
    1. Encourage a healthy social and political interdependence among urban and rural areas
      • Number of regional cooperative arrangements in law enforcement, emergency services, social services/ delivery
      • Number of cultural, sports, educational and service groups that draw participants from across jurisdictional lines
      • Money from each jurisdiction budget for joint governmental; programs
      • Number of joint plans adopted
    1. Take responsibility for the indirect and induced impacts of the community on other regions in solid waste, population growth, economic activity, social problems, air/water quality and quantity:
      • Number of businesses that are ISO 14001 certified
      • Measure our ecological footprint (accounting tool used to determine resource consumption and waste assimilation requirements of a defined human population)
    1. Increase the use of renewable energy resources:
      • Alternative energy use as a percentage of total energy use
    1. Increase the efficiency of energy use through conservation measures:
      • Per capita energy consumption
    1. Assess all costs and benefits of major public and private decisions from immediate, long-term and cumulative prospective:
      • Number and percentage of major decisions (public/private) that are informed by studies employing the methods and techniques of long-term, comprehensive and benefit cost accounting.
    1. Involve individuals in neighbourhoods and organizations:
      • Membership in neighbourhood associations and selected organizations
      • Amount of time volunteered in public service organizations (from a pre-determined list)
      • Amount of money donated to local charities or its equivalent
    1. Involve individuals in government:
      • Number and percent registered to vote
      • Percentage of total registered that votes
      • Number of persons participating in public hearings
      • In opinion survey, percent feeling that they are able to influence governmental decisions
    1. Recognize that the long-term welfare of human and natural immunities may require individual and self-restraint:
      • Number of adopted comprehensive plans that use longer than 20 year long goals
    1. Governments provide needed services and infrastructure for citizens, especially with an eye to the future:
      • Public perception of quality and availability of governmental services received, in opinion survey
    1. Taxation should be equitable, progressive, relatively easy to collect and either neutral or beneficial in its impact on sustainability of the region:
      • Number of governmental revenue sources that do and do not meet that standard, and percent of government revenue received from each.

    NATURAL RESOURCES

    Natural Environment

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Agriculture/ Forestry

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    1. Water quality and quantity are sufficient to support the region's human population and biological resources:
      • Number of wells that have gone dry
      • Water quality parameters (sediment, BOD, etc)
      • Diversity of aquatic organisms
      • Total annual water use by sector (residential, industrial, agricultural, commercial)
      • Seasonality and duration of water stage level or urban waterways compared to that of rural waterways
    1. Ecosystems exist which contain adequate habitat to support viable populations of the plant and animal communities representative of the region's biological diversity:
      • Population trends of indicator species by each habitat type
      • Habitat Suitability Index for indicator species by each habitat type
      • Vegetation cover by patch size and type
    1. Air quality does not negatively impact the region's biological and geological resources:
      • Tons of toxins released per annum into the environment
      • Ozone levels in urban areas as compared to back group levels in rural areas
      • Net oxygen production, or amount produced/amount consumed
    1. Soil loss does not exceed inputs from deposition and new soil forming processes:
      • Net soil loss rate
    1. Natural areas exist which serve the spiritual, social and economic needs of human communities:
      • Acres of land not subject to extractive uses (forestry, mining, agriculture etc.) or damaging human uses.
    1. Promote a full spectrum of local, national and international marketing of local agricultural products:
      • Median profits of individual farms in the region per annum
    1. Promote local direct marketing of locally produced agricultural products:
      • Gross proceeds of direct farm sales (incl. Farm market proceeds) per annum
      • Legal impediments to direct farm sales of agricultural products removed
    1. Encourage the development of local businesses and industries that create finished goods from local agricultural (and forestry) products and their by-products:
      • Gross sales per annum of local value-added goods made with local agricultural products
    1. Make buying locally a more convenient and available option for consumers
      • Percentage of locally produced agricultural products bought locally
    1. Promote retention of farmland for the future:
      • Number, size and types of farms in each county
      • Number of acres in Ag/Forestal Districts
      • Number of acres in land use assessment program (agriculture, forestry, horticulture, open space categories) in each county
      • Number of acres per county lost annually to non-qualifying uses
      • Percent of localities' tax burden borne by agricultural and forestral lands
      • Loss of productive farm (and forest) land to other uses per annum
      • Number of acres under perpetual open-space or conservation easement
    1. Promote the use of farming practices which combine cost efficiency, environmental soundness:
      • Percent of farms using soil conservation practices
    1. Broaden the practice of sustainable forestry among loggers and landowners:
      • Total forest area and its percentage by type and age classification
      • Acreage of forest land in private and in public ownership
    1. Maintain or improve, where possible, the quality and long-term productivity of timber for use as wood products:
      • Annual removals compared to annual net growth by species group for timber and non-timber products
      • Value added to timber production by local manufacturing
      • Direct and indirect employment in the forestry and agricultural sectors
    1. Encourage local governments to identify the areas best suited for forestry and use local planning and land use tools and fiscal policy to retain the resource base:
      • Acreage in Ag./Forestal Districts
      • Acreage in conservation/ open space easements
    1. Promote a full spectrum of local, national and international marketing for local forest products:
      • Value of local timber and non-timber forest products used locally
      • Value of local timber and non-timber forest products exported from the region
    1. Provide forest recreational and educational opportunities and tourism:
      • Visitors per day and dollars spent for forest recreation and tourism
    1. Inform and educate the public about the importance of managing and protecting forest resources:
      • Number of school programs by the Department of Forestry per year.

     

    The Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions "Indicators of Sustainable Development for the United Kingdom"

    http://www.environment.detr.gov.uk/epsim/indics/isda01t.htm

     

    Category & Indicators

     

    Discussion

    ECONOMY

    1. Domestic Product Gross
    2.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

    3. Structure of the economy
    4.  

       

       

       

       

    5. Expenditure components of GDP and personal savings
    6.  

       

       

       

       

       

    7. Consumer expenditure
    8.  

       

       

    9. Inflation
    10.  

    11. Employment
    12.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

    13. Government borrowing and debt
    14.  

       

       

       

       

       

    15. Pollution abatement expenditure
    16.  

    17. Infant mortality
    18.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

    19. Life expectancy

     

    1. The rate of growth of GDP is the main indicator of the speed with which the economy is expanding. If sustained over time, growth in GDP per head will lead to general increases in the standard of living. However, the relationship between growth in GDP and sustainable development is not straightforward. Other things being equal, growth is clearly desirable and, indeed, the objective of the Government's economic policy is "to promote sustained economic growth and rising prosperity". Beyond this, it is hard to generalize. Higher economic activity reflected in higher GDP may increase pollution, or rest upon depletion of scarce natural resources. But, equally growth may raise demands for higher environmental standards and a healthy economy is more able to afford environmental goods, thus improving the future quality of life and promoting sustainability. Published figures for GDP do not take proper account of factors such as these and in some cases can be positively misleading, e.g. expenditure on preventing pollution is counted as a positive component of GDP. This has led to calls for the development of environmental or "green" accounts, which make proper allowance for environmental impacts. But the issues involved, such as the valuation of the damage of pollution, are complex and the development of such accounts is still at a very early stage. Even green parallel for a proper consideration of sustainable development.
    2. The structure of the economy - that is, the relative size and activity of the various sectors of the economy - has a considerable potential impact on the environment. Consumption of natural resources, use of energy, the types and volumes of pollutants and waste produced are all dependent on the activities of the various sectors. This indicator shows the contribution of key sectors to GDP since 1970. This indicator has been included to give a background picture of changes in the economy which have an indirect impact on the environment, by influencing the patterns of consumption and generation of pollution and waste.
    3. As well as disaggregating GDP by sector, GDP can be broken down by types of spending: investment, consumption, stockbuilding and net trade. Investment expenditure adds to the capital stock that will be available to produce goods and services in future years. Public and private consumption, on the other hand, represent current consumption of resources, although a significant fraction of consumer's expenditure - usually between 5 to 10 per cent - is on durable goods. Investment also uses up resources and ever-higher levels of investment would not be efficient. Stockbuilding can oscillate from year to year and has little implication for sustainable development. It is for people to choose freely how to spend their incomes. To the extent which they choose to save, this may contribute to the amount of finance available to industry. With an aging population, too low a saving rate might jeopardize consumption levels in the future.
    4. Consumer expenditure is a measure of the economic benefit which people derive from a growing economy in the form of the ability to buy goods and services. It also reflects change in demand, which may impact on the environment directly and indirectly through changing patterns of consumption of raw materials, water and energy, greater production of waste and pollution, greater demand for travel etc.
    5. Inflation is relevant for economic growth, because economies work most efficiently when inflation is low and stable. If inflation is rising persistently, it may indicate that the economy is overheating and that the rate of growth is therefore not sustainable.
    6. A healthy economy provides employment (and self-employment) which produces income for individuals, businesses and government and enables them to improve living standards. There is no "correct" level of employment, as the size of the workforce depends on the number of people of working age and how many of them are economically active. Some unemployment is also inevitable as members of the workforce move from one job to another. However, ever-increasing levels of unemployment, or falling levels of employment, are not sustainable in the long term. The implications of the split of employment between different sectors for sustainable development are less clear cut, and the considerations discussed under Indicator 2 (the structure of the economy) are also relevant.
    7. The Public Sector Borrowing Requirement (PSBR) is a measure of the Government's annual borrowing. If it is rising persistently, and the ratio of debt to GDP is high and rising, corrective action by the Government would be required, either by raising taxes or cutting expenditure. Servicing high and rising levels of Governments debt could lead to high interest rates for private sector businesses, depressing investment and growth. It is Government policy that the PSBR should be brought back towards balance over the medium term. Other indicators of the public finances, which may have some relevance for sustainable development, are the ratios of public spending and taxes to GDP. High taxation and high Government spending may reduce incentives and so reduce the long run rate of growth of the economy.
    8. A healthy economy can free up resources, enabling us to spend more on protecting the environment. An indicator of expenditure on environmental protection, viewed alongside indicators of environmental quality, gives an overall measure of the resources expended on dealing with environmental pollution.
    9. Much of the policy of environmental protection is intended to protect human health from adverse effects of environmental pollution. However, in most cases it is very difficult to link specific illness with any particular environmental factor. Ill health can be caused or exacerbated by a variety of conditions including lifestyle (e.g. smoking, lack of exercise, diet), genetic traits, other economic and social factors, as well as by the weather and hazards in the environment. In the UK, incidences of illness which can be directly attributed to specific environmental pollution is, in general, very localized and usually short term. Nevertheless, the health of the population is important to sustainable development, and two widely and internationally accepted measures are rates of infant mortality and average life expectancy.
    10. Advances in medical treatment and improvements in standards of living have contributed to significant changes in average life expectancy, even over the last 20 years. Not only does this indicate a generally healthier population, but it also has economic and social implications - more people living longer means a larger population of elderly people relative to those of working age. Public provision for pensions, health and community care will need to be financially supported by a relatively smaller population in work.

    TRANSPORTATION

    1. Car use and total passenger travel
    2.  

       

    3. Short journeys
    4.  

       

       

       

       

    5. Real changes in the cost of transport
    6.  

       

       

    7. Freight traffic

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    1. The Government is taking steps to influence the growth in demand for transport by attempting to ensure that people pay the full social and environmental cost of their transport decisions, so improving the overall efficiency of those decisions for the economy as a whole and bringing environmental benefits. Key indicators included in this section are car use and total passenger travel, mode of travel for short journeys, transport pricing, and the volume of freight transport.
    2. Government policy is to encourage people to use more environmentally friendly forms of travel. Walking and cycling are the least damaging methods of travel. Research shows that most journeys on foot are less than 1 mile, with some at up to 2 miles. Few people walk further than 2 miles. For cycling, the threshold is around 5 miles. Many people are unable to walk or cycle and for them a bus, where practicable, is often the next best environmental option for short trips. Indicator shows the number of trips per person per year made by mode of transport for journeys of less than 1, 1 to 2, and 2 to 5 miles.
    3. The Government has accepted the need to influence the growth in demand for travel, as part of the wider strategy to stabilize carbon dioxide emissions and to make people pay the full cost of their travel decisions. One of the ways of doing this is through price, and the Government has already announced plans to increase the real price of fuel by increasing fuel duty by an average 5 per cent per year. Indicator shows the real change in price of passenger fares and motoring, in comparison with the growth in real personal disposable income.
    4. Goods vehicles (over 3.5 tonnes gross weight) account for around 7 per cent of total vehicle traffic. As with passenger transport, the average distance traveled is increasing. There has been strong growth in road haulage, which has been influenced by the removal of quantitative restrictions on road haulage in 1970, larger vehicles and changing distribution methods. In recent years, growth in the number of the heaviest permitted vehicles contributed to an overall reduction in the numbers of goods vehicles. As a result of the diversification of many small, service industries, there has also been considerable increase in the use of light goods vehicles. As a result of the competitiveness and greater flexibility of road haulage and reductions in traditional staple traffics, particularly coal, the importance of rail freight, in terms of the amounts lifted and moved, has declined. Most long distance traffic goes by road. Indicator compares the annual trends in road and rail freight lifted and moved since 1970.

    LEISURE and TOURISM

    1. Leisure journeys
    2.  

       

       

       

       

    3. Air travel

     

     

     

    1. Leisure is one of the most significant reasons why people travel, accounting for around 41 per cent of passenger mileage each year. Leisure travel is a fast growing aspect of transport use. As with other passenger travel, most leisure journeys are made by car - 81 per cent between 1992 and 1994. Leisure includes visiting friends and sporting and entertainment activities which mainly take place locally, day trips to the countryside or the coast, and longer trips, including trips abroad, on holiday. Indicator shows the average miles traveled per person per year for each of the main leisure purposes.
    2. Trends in leisure travel can be useful indicators not simply of the direct impacts of transport, but also of the wider impacts of tourism and leisure destinations (e.g. economic impacts, changes in land use and overcrowding). Looking at air travel can give some idea of the trends in international tourism as well as domestic. Air travel itself has direct impacts on sustainable development. Carbon dioxide emissions per passenger-mile and per freight tonne-mile are generally higher for air transport than for most other modes. Other types of emissions from aircraft, especially nitrogen oxides, can contribute to atmospheric and local air quality problems (although emissions per passenger-mile are expected to fall as a result of technological developments, fuel efficiency improvements and internationally-agreed regulations). The most significant local environmental impact of aviation is noise. Unlike some other impacts noise has only a transistory effect. But the development of transport infrastructure can have long-term implications for noise. Indicator shows numbers of passengers per year arriving at and departing from UK airports on overseas leisure trips since 1975.

    ENERGY

    1. Depletion of fossil fuels
    2.  

       

       

    3. Capacity of nuclear and renewable fuels
    4.  

       

       

       

    5. Primary and final energy consumption
    6.  

       

       

       

       

    7. Energy consumption and output
    8. Industrial and commercial sector consumption
    9. Road transport energy use
    10.  

    11. Residential energy use

     

     

    1. Developed economies such as the UK are critically dependent on the supply of energy and a prime sustainable development aim is to ensure that future generations can enjoy a quality of energy services comparable to that enjoyed today. The way in which energy is produced, supplied and consumed is one of the major ways in which human activity affects the environment.
    2. Use of nuclear and renewable sources of energy has considerable benefits, not only in reducing demand for non-renewable fossil fuels, but also in producing lower environmental impacts in terms of carbon dioxide emissions and air pollution. However, possible environmental disadvantages of particular schemes in terms of the effect on landscape or noise, for example, also have to be considered through the planning system. Nuclear power generation also generates radioactive waste which needs to be disposed of safely. Indicator shows the net capacity of nuclear and renewable resources for electricity generation from 1990 to 1994.
    3. An examination of the trends in primary and final energy consumption, in total and by sector, can illuminate the way in which energy is used to derive economic benefits for the community. The major user categories which are examined are industry, services, transport and households. While trends in the amounts of fuel consumed are relevant, it is also important to monitor their relationships with other indicators to determine their effectiveness of use. Comparisons are therefore made with GDP and value added, traffic growth and, for domestic consumption, with the number of households. Indicator shows the trends in primary and final energy consumption since 1970.
    4. Indicator shows the relationship of primary energy consumption to GDP since 1970.
    5. Indicator shows industrial, commercial and public sector energy consumption since 1970 compared with the value added by the two sectors.
    6. Indicator compares road passenger vehicle fuel consumption with the number of passenger-miles traveled, and road freight vehicle fuel consumption with the number of tonne-miles moved since 1970.
    7. Indicator contrasts the trends in domestic energy consumption with the number of households

    LAND USE

    1. Land covered by urban development
    2.  

       

       

    3. Household numbers
    4.  

       

       

       

       

       

    5. Re-use of land in urban uses for development
    6.  

       

       

       

    7. Stock and reclamation of derelict land
    8.  

       

       

       

    9. Road building
    10.  

       

       

       

       

    11. Out-of-town retail floorspace
    12.  

       

       

    13. Regular journeys
    14.  

       

       

       

       

    15. Regular expenditure
    16.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

    17. Green spaces in urban areas

     

    1. The spread of urban development, the consequent loss of rural land and the associated impacts on the environment are important areas of concern. There is a continuing need to reconcile the requirements for additional land for important uses such as housing, industry, commerce and retailing with a desire to protect the countryside and agriculture. More recently, concern about sustainable development, and in particular about the need to reduce travel demand through land use planning controls, has added to interest in the extent and location of urbanization.
    2. Demand for housing constitutes the main pressure for increased use of rural land for development. This demand is being driven more by changes in lifestyle than by an increasing population. Over the last century the population has doubled but the number of houses has quadrupled, reflecting a large decline in household size. People are living longer and increasingly on their own, through choice, or through death of a partner, or as a result of marriage break-ups. The pressure for new housing is expected to continue in the first part of the next century, as overall population increases and current trends in the age structure and marital status of the population are maintained.
    3. The re-use of land in urban uses, particularly for housing and commercial development, contributes to reducing the pressures on the countryside to accommodate new development. Commercial and residential redevelopment within existing urban areas helps to maintain their vitality and viability. It can also improve the general quality of life and also accessibility for those people without a car by increasing and widening the range of services and facilities available and thereby reducing the need for people to travel to other towns for work, shopping and leisure.
    4. Reclamation and regeneration of derelict land in both urban and rural areas minimizes the pressure to develop greenfield sites. It can also help to revitalize local environments, particularly urban areas, by removing unsightly developments and providing land suitable for housing, employment and leisure uses. Indicator shows the stock of derelict land in England and the area justifying reclamation from surveys undertaken in 1982, 1988 and 1993. It also shows the area of derelict land reclaimed on an annualized basis and the area of derelict land which has been brought into beneficial use on an annualized basis during 1982-88 and 1988-93.
    5. Businesses and communities need to have reasonable access to goods, services and other people, and an adequate road network is part of the solution. The pressure to build roads has increased in recent years with the growth in car ownership. Economic growth has allowed people to make more use of their cars and has also resulted in rapid increases in the amount of freight transported by road. These factors have increased the pressure for using rural and previously urban land for building new roads in GB. Indicator shows the area of urban and rural land in England used to build new roads during the second half of the 1980s.
    6. The development of out-of-town shopping centres and retail parks has contributed to the rundown of town and city centres. Reduced retail activity in urban areas can have a knock-on effect on other services, such as entertainment, leisure, banking, etc. Out-of-town retail developments also encourage people to travel longer distances for shopping, mainly in cars, which causes increased congestion, pollution and noise. Indicator shows the growth in the gross lettable area (GLA) of out-of-town shopping centres between 1970 and 1993.
    7. Cars account for around 59 per cent of all journeys. More people are able to afford cars and are using them for commuting and travelling greater distances, as a result of changes in the location of residential and retail development, and employment patterns. People are also using their cars more for leisure purposes (see Indicator c1 in the Leisure and tourism section). In addition, more parents are driving their children to schools, many of which are further from home. Indicator f7 shows trends in the average lengths for commuting, shopping and taking children to and from school.
    8. The Government promotes sustainable regeneration, economic development and competitiveness in England through the targeted Single Regeneration Budget (SRB). The SRB Challenge Fund supports comprehensive regeneration strategies developed by local partnerships between the public, private and voluntary sectors to help improve the quality of life of local people. In deprived rural areas, support is mainly channeled through the Rural Development Programme and Rural Challenge. The amount spent by Government on such regeneration programmes gives an indication of the rate at which urban and rural land is being regenerated and put to beneficial use. Indicator shows the amount of actual and planned Government funding for regeneration in England between 1989/90 and 1997/98.
    9. Future indicator development: Green spaces in urban areas are important for recreational purposes and for generally enhancing the quality of life of people who live in urban areas. It is therefore important that they are maintained and developed both in terms of area and environmental quality, and not lost to development or allowed to fall into disrepair. No comprehensive and validated data exist on the extent of urban green spaces.

    WATER RESOURCES

    1. Licensed abstractions and effective rainfall
    2.  

       

       

    3. Low flow alleviation
    4.  

       

       

       

    5. Abstraction by use
    6.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

    7. Abstractions for public water supply
    8.  

       

       

    9. Demand and supply of public water
    10. Abstractions for spray irrigation

     

    1. Although in total the available water resources in the UK well exceed demand, the balance between these varies widely from region to region. Many parts of the UK have had to develop river basin management systems to ensure that water can be reused between its falling as rain and its eventual return to the sea. This occurs particularly in the Thames basin where recycling of abstracted water takes place along the whole length of the Thames. Indicator compares licensed abstractions and effective drought rainfall.
    2. River flows in Britain reflect, not just the balance between rainfall and evaporation, but also the effects of abstractions to meet demand from the domestic, industrial, and agricultural sectors. The effects of increasing demand can give rise to unacceptably low flows in rivers, thereby damaging wildlife habitats and having adverse effects on water quality, and recreational and amenity value. Indicator shows the length of rivers in low flow alleviation schemes in England and Wales affected by over-abstractions since 1990/91.
    3. Water is drawn from both surface freshwater resources, such as rivers and lakes, and from groundwater resources held in water-bearing rocks known as aquifers. Substantial amounts of water are also drawn from estuarial waters, although these are excluded from the discussions here. Many industrial abstractions, such as those for hydroelectric power by electricity companies and for cooling, agricultural abstractions and for fish farming do not consume water resources. Virtually all of the water abstracted is later discharged back to surface water and the total volume abstracted is therefore of less importance environmentally. However, the quality of the water discharged is not necessarily of the same quality when it is discharged as it was when abstracted. In contrast, uses such as spray irrigation and abstractions for evaporative cooling represent loss to the water resource.
    4. Much of the population is concentrated in the drier parts of south and east of England where river flows and water resources are particularly vulnerable to variations in climate. Increasing affluence and higher standards of living are changing water demand patterns. The main increases in domestic water use are for personal hygiene and for watering of gardens in summer, when supplies are under most stress. Indicator shows abstractions for public water supply per head in England and Wales since 1984 together with present patterns of water use by households.

     

    1. Although abstractions for spray irrigation represent only a small proportion (less than 1 per cent) of annual abstractions they can be significant because they are immediately consumptive (i.e. little water is returned to the system due to retention in the crop and/or evapotranspiration), they occur in a concentrated period usually in the drier parts of the country and can vary greatly from year to year, peaking in dry years when surface water is scarcest.

    CLIMATE CHANGE

    1. Global greenhouse gas radiative forcing rate
    2. Global temperature change
    3. Emissions of greenhouse gases
    4.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

    5. Power station emissions of carbon dioxide

     

     

     

    1. Indicator shows global annual temperature variations since 1858 and annual temperature variations since 1660.
    2. Indicator shows the trends since 1970 in UK estimated emissions of greenhouse gases and total emissions in relation to the change in GDP. Global Warming Potentials (GWPs) provide a relative index which allows the radiative effects of emissions of each greenhouse gas to be compared. Relative to carbon dioxide (GWP = 1.0), the latest GWP estimate for methane is 24.5 and for nitrous oxide 320 over a 100-year time horizon, although considerable uncertainty surrounds these figures. These weights have been applied to annual estimates of UK emissions of carbon dioxide and methane since 1970 and to nitrous oxide since 1990, the earliest year for which UK estimates are available, to give an overall UK global warming index. Although the GWP for carbon dioxide is lower than for other greenhouse gases, emissions of carbon dioxide are much larger so carbon dioxide has the greatest impact on global warming.
    3. Indicator shows emissions of carbon dioxide from power stations between 1970 and 1993 in relation to the amount of electricity generated from UK sources.

    WILDLIFE AND HABITATS

    1. Native species at risk
    2.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

    3. Breeding birds
    4.  

       

       

       

       

       

    5. Plant diversity in semi-improved grassland
    6.  

       

       

       

       

    7. Habitat fragmentation
    8.  

    9. Lakes and ponds.
    10.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

    11. Plant diversity in streamsides
    12.  

       

    13. Mammal populations
    14.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

    15. Dragonfly distributions
    16.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

    17. Butterfly distributions

     

    1. Indicator shows estimated proportions of GB native species under threat or nationally scarce. This indicator provides a broad-brush measure of the extent and status of biodiversity in GB. Comparable information is not available for the UK as a whole. The indicator gives the proportions of four groups of species that are considered to be "threatened" (i.e. endangered, vulnerable, or rare based on criteria devised by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN)) and, where available, the proportions which are "nationally scarce" (i.e. species recorded as present in only 16 -100 ten km squares in GB). "Threatened" (i.e. Red Data Listed) and "nationally scarce" species are used in evaluating the conservation importance of sites and their presence is one of the criteria used to select Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs).
    2. Birds provide several advantages as representative indicators of the broad state of wildlife and the countryside. They are wide-ranging in habitat distribution and tend to be at or near the top of the food chain. Their mobility and the relatively long life expectancies of some species can result in the integration of environmental effects over large areas and long time spans. In addition, birds are generally well studied and monitored and reasonably reliable data on population and geographical distribution are available over time. Indicator shows the numbers of GB breeding bird species increasing and declining in population size and geographical distribution, by broad habitat type.
    3. Semi-natural grassland is a good quality habitat found in the wider countryside in the UK, some of which may have originated naturally before human clearance of shrubs and trees, but most of which owes its existence to prehistoric farmers. There are many different types of grassland which support a diverse range of plants and animals in lowland areas. The wildlife in these areas is best sustained by traditional, low-intensity management, e.g. as hay meadows and grazing pastures. The application of fertilizers or herbicides (i.e. grassland "improvement") can eliminate all but a few common, tolerant species. Indicator shows changes in the number of different plant species found in semi-improved grassland (used as a proxy for semi-natural grassland) in GB.
    4. Future indicator development: Fragmentation is an important issue for a number of other habitats, e.g. woodlands, heathlands, etc. Work currently being done to monitor changes in parcel size may be used for future national indicators for different habitats.
    5. Indicator shows estimates of the numbers of lakes and ponds in GB between 1945 and 1990. Lakes and ponds have value as wildlife habitats, landscape features, and recreational amenities. Ponds are important because they are widespread and provide aquatic habitats in otherwise terrestrial environments. They thus form additional havens of biodiversity in these environments, as many plants and animals live in the water or at the water edge, or use them in one stage of their life cycle. Ponds were once a vital feature of many farms, used for watering livestock, but changing farming practices have made ponds largely redundant and many have disappeared. However, since the late 1980s a number of measures have been taken which may eventually arrest this decline. These include changes to the Common Agricultural Policy, and the introduction of more environmental land management schemes.
    6. Like hedges, stream banks contain many plant species which are absent or rare in them surrounding landscape, and they therefore form an important reservoir of plant biodiversity. Stream banks also form an integral part of the aquatic environment, with many animals dependent on both the quality of the stream's water and the environmental quality of its banks. They also form important corridors between different habitat sites.
    7. Mammals are a useful group of species for monitoring biodiversity, because they are widespread, easy to identify, present in large numbers, and include species that might potentially serve as good indicators of a variety of changes in the countryside. For example, some mammals such as deer and rabbits (which are increasing in population) have a significant impact through their grazing on plant diversity and hence influence habitat quality and other species within their ecosystem. Other mammals such as the mountain hare, yellow-necked mouse, and the common dormouse (which may be declining in numbers) may form good indicators at different scales of habitat fragmentation. Others such as the hedgehog, brown hare, harvest mouse, stoat, and weasel (which may also be all declining) may be good monitors of the wider countryside, particularly arable land.
    8. Dragonflies breed in a variety of aquatic habitats in GB, including rivers, streams and ditches, lakes and ponds, and bogs, heaths and moorlands. They are reliant on the water from which they emerge, and on habitats surrounding the water which provide feeding areas. Some species are highly specialized to a single or narrow range of habitats, while others are tolerant of a wide variety of habitat types and water quality. Dragonfly populations can be adversely affected by both loss of habitats (e.g. the loss of ponds, the lowering of water levels in rivers and wetlands, etc) and habitat degradation (e.g. through water pollution, adverse management of marginal vegetation, etc). Different species vary in their sensitivity to pollution, which means that it may be possible to gauge the health of an aquatic habitat by the species of dragonflies present.
    9. Figures for butterfly species can be used to reflect the health and quality of some land-based habitats, just as dragonflies can be used for aquatic habitats. Butterfly populations can be adversely affected by both loss of habitats and habitat degradation, and are also very sensitive to the climate. Like dragonflies, some species of butterfly are highly specialized to a particular habitat or are sensitive to changes in habitat management and agricultural practices, while others are tolerant of a wide range of variation in habitat type and quality. Different species vary in their sensitivity to pollution, which means that it may be possible to gauge the health of some habitats (e.g. chalk grassland) by the species of butterflies present

    LAND COVER AND LANDSCAPE

    1. Rural land cover: Indicator shows the stock of rural land (excluding forestry) in GB in 1990 and changes in stock for broad categories between 1984 and 1990
    2. Designated and protected areas Indicator shows trends in the extent of designated and protected areas in the UK
    3.  

       

       

       

       

    4. Agricultural productivity: Indicator shows agricultural inputs and outputs since the mid-1940s and agricultural productivity as measured by the ratio of inputs to outputs.
    5. Nitrogen usage: Indicator shows agricultural outputs compared with nitrogen inputs to soils.
    6.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

    7. Pesticide usage: Indicator shows the average amount of active ingredient applied per hectare of cereals for different types of pesticides
    8.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

    9. Environmentally managed land

     

     

    1. Agricultural land dominates the rural landscape of the UK. Changes in agricultural practices have the potential to cause positive environmental effects, such as the maintenance of valued landscapes and habitats by environmentally-friendly farming practices, as well as negative ones, such as the loss of hedgerows and walls. The drive for increased food production since the mid-1940s has resulted in an intensification of production and environmental pressures on landscapes and habitats, in particular semi-natural habitats such as ancient meadows, heaths and wetlands. Alongside agriculture, urbanization and afforestation are the other main drivers of change in rural land cover in the UK.
    2. Landscapes and habitats in the UK, and a number of plant and animal species, have been influenced by human activities over the centuries. In recent decades, urban and transport development, together with agricultural intensification, have led to the deterioration or loss of some areas of land with landscape or habitat value. National and international legislation aims to protect the areas which are of special interest or outstanding quality and a number of different types of designations have been introduced for this purpose. These areas do not receive unlimited protection, rather in each case every attempt is made to strike a balance between the importance of the site for biodiversity conservation and other economic, social and health needs. Therefore, in many protected areas, limited development and economic activity continues to take place. In many cases, continuation of the latter is essential for the maintenance of the character of the landscape.
    3. Efficient use of rural land, in particular arable land and grassland, is important for maintaining a healthy, economic and social balance in rural areas and for ensuring an adequate supply of good quality food. However, as consumers expect to be able to buy an ever-wider choice of foods (not just exotic foods, but out of season products as well), self-sufficiency in agriculture is unlikely and is not, in any case, an objective of policy.
    4.  

       

    5. Nitrogen is vital for the growing of crops and rearing of livestock for food. It is contained in mineral fertilizer, organic wastes such as manures and slurries, and animal feed. Atmospheric nitrogen is also fixed in the soil by legumes. However, because crops and animals are naturally inefficient at utilizing it, only a proportion of the nitrogen applied to agriculture ends up in food and other products. The quantity, timing, and method of application also affects the efficiency with which nitrogen is taken up by crops and animals. Nitrogen that is not consumed in agricultural products is transformed in soil, air, and water in the "nitrogen cycle", a complex process influenced by many interacting factors. Some forms of nitrogen can have adverse effects on the environment (e.g. excess nitrate in freshwater) whilst others are benign (e.g. nitrogen gas, which makes up 80 per cent of the atmosphere). Protein is required by humans and animals to sustain life and is contained in crops and livestock products. It is comprised largely of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen. However, protein production is mostly driven by nitrogen availability.
    6. Pesticides are important to modern agriculture and also have significant non-agricultural uses to control pests, weeds, and diseases. However, they can have an adverse effect on the environment, by impacting on non-target species of plants, insects and aquatic life, and by contaminating water abstracted for public supply. Government policy is to encourage the minimization of pesticide use through a strict approvals process, and appropriate research and development. In this context minimization means that the amounts of pesticides used should be limited to the minimum necessary for the effective control of pests compatible with the protection of human health and the environment. The levels of selected pesticides found in rivers and groundwater are covered by Indicator in the Freshwater quality section. About 340 different chemicals are used as active ingredients in agricultural pesticides and formulated into some 3,400 different products. This indicator can thus give only a broad guide to trends in pesticide inputs to agriculture. Cereals are the predominant UK crop, and pesticides applied to cereals currently account for 34 per cent of pesticide usage. The trends for cereals are typical of the situation with most other crops.
    7. Over the centuries, much of the rural landscape has been shaped by agriculture and continued management is essential to maintain the characteristics and quality which are so much a part of our natural heritage. However, many aspects of good land management are not readily quantifiable, particularly on a national scale. As a proxy, therefore, this indicator shows the extent of land covered by land management agreements, which are designed to ensure that land is managed in an environmentally friendly way, and to conserve or re-create valued landscapes and wildlife habitats, including the promotion of better management of features such as hedgerows and traditional stone walls.

    FRESHWATER QUALITY

    1. River quality - chemical and biological: Indicator shows trends in the proportion of river and canal lengths in the UK
    2. Nitrates in rivers and groundwater
    3.  

       

    4. Phosphorous in rivers
    5. Pesticides in rivers and groundwater
    6.  

       

       

       

       

       

    7. Pollution incidents: Indicator shows major and significant substantiated water pollution incidents in England by source since 1991.
    8. Pollution prevention and control
    9.  

    10. Expenditure on water abstraction, treatment and distribution
    11.  

       

       

       

    12. Expenditure on sewage treatment

     

    1. The quality of rivers and canals in the UK is influenced by a variety of factors - discharges from sewage works and industrial installations, pollution incidents and deposition, leaching and run-off from rural and contaminated land, as well as levels of rainfall and water abstraction. Regular chemical and biological surveys provide a general indication of the quality of rivers and canals across the UK.
    2. The presence of various nutrients in excessive quantities in water, combined with particular weather conditions, can lead to eutrophication (excessive algal growth). This can cause long-term ecosystem disruption by oxygen depletion, which adversely affects fish, and by-production of toxins, which are potentially poisonous to other animals. The nutrients in the UK which generally lead to this are nitrate in marine or coastal waters and phosphorus in freshwater.
    3. Indicator shows annual average phosphorus concentrations in GB rivers by landscape category.
    4. The UK has developed the "Red List" of the most dangerous substances in water, including pesticides and heavy metals, scientifically selected for their persistent toxic and bioaccumulative characteristics. Pesticides are important to modern agriculture and also have significant non-agricultural uses to control pests, weeds, and diseases. However, they can have an adverse effect on the aquatic environment, and, if present in significant quantities in water abstracted for public supply, treatment to remove them is necessary. There are currently about 450 active ingredients approved for use as pesticides in the UK; about 340 of these are used as agricultural pesticides. The majority of pesticides detected most frequently in water are herbicides used for non-agriculture purposes.
    5. The NRA, Scottish River Purification Authorities, and the Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions for Northern Ireland monitor aspects of water quality in England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland respectively. Consents are issued to control point source discharges to water at a level consistent with the achievement of quality objectives for the waters concerned and their users. However, occasionally consents are breached or other incidents occur at points where no consent has been issued which lead to pollution, e.g. accidental spillage and storm overflows. Local inland water quality can be adversely affected by a variety of pollution incidents, with most incidents caused either by sewage, industry, or agriculture.
    6. This indicator is concerned with compliance with monitored numeric consents by sewage treatment works operated by the water and sewerage undertakers, trade discharges (which will include site drainage as well as discharges from industrial processes) and privately operated sewage treatment works (in some cases these may be little more than septic tanks).
    7. One of the key sustainable development issues relating to drinking water quality is to ensure that adequate freshwater resources of sufficient quality are available for abstraction for treatment as drinking water. A secure supply of clean water is essential for both human health and quality of life. The issues surrounding the supply and quality of drinking water are extremely complex. Different water sources provide water of widely varying quality, and so the necessary treatment can vary from simple disinfection to multistage treatment. The cost of water treatment may thus reflect to some extent the quality of this source water, but also a wide range of other factors such as the efficiency with which particular pollutants can be treated, drinking water standards, etc.
    8. The key sustainable development issues relating to waste water treatment (including sewage and industrial effluent) are to maintain and, as necessary, improve the quality of waters receiving waste water effluent discharges, to promote the natural environment and biodiversity, and to ensure adequate water resources are available for particular uses. The polluting load of the effluent, and hence water quality in the area of the discharge, will depend on the level of treatment provided.

    SOIL

    1. Soil quality: Indicator shows trends in concentrations of organic matter, acidity and concentrations of phosphorus and potassium in agricultural topsoils in England and Wales.
    2.  

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

       

    3. Heavy metals in topsoils: Indicator t2 shows concentrations of some of the most important heavy metals in agricultural topsoils in England and Wales.

     

    1. Loss of soil function is an important issue for sustainable development, since soil is essential for food and timber production and also provides habitats for many plant and animal species. It also has other important functions, including the ability to filter, transform and neutralize potentially polluting substances which can enter the soil from rainfall or as a result of human activities. It can act as an important reservoir for water, as a physical base for buildings and as a sink for carbon sequestrated from the atmosphere (see section on Climate change). Organic matter is important for the development of soil structure and contributes to soil stability. Its adsorption properties help to regulate the movements of pollutants and contaminants in soils. Organic matter also plays an important role in the cycling and storage of plant nutrients, which are vital for food production, and low organic matter concentrations can increase the risk of erosion. Many soil organisms obtain their energy supply from the breakdown of organic matter. High organic matter concentrations can increase nitrate leaching and emissions of methane and nitrous oxide. Maintaining pH in arable soils at suitable levels is important for soil productivity and overall soil fertility. Productivity can be reduced as soils become acidic. The UK's climate tends to increase the acidification of soils by the leaching of nutrients. This is the result of rainfall exceeding evaporation and because of the natural acidity of rainfall, even when unpolluted. In those areas where soils are not naturally calcareous, farmers protect their soils from acidification by regular additions of lime so as to maintain production potential. Highly acidic soils can also cause the mobilization of heavy metals which have accumulated naturally through the soil formation process or as a consequence of contamination, for example, as a result of atmospheric deposition of industrial emissions. Once mobilized, heavy metals can leach into, and contaminate, surface and groundwaters. Crop growth is dependent upon the availability of plant nutrients such as phosphorus and potassium, therefore maintaining an adequate supply of these and other nutrients in soil is necessary to obtain optimum crop performance. Accumulation can occur where the application of fertilizers and manures is regularly greater than off-take in crops. Yields are likely to be restricted when soils are deficient in these major nutrients even where extra fertilizers are applied within the crop year.
    2. Some soils can be naturally contaminated but human activities have increased metal concentrations in many others. Metal-based industries, fossil fuel burning, waste incineration, chemical industries and the use of leaded petrol have all contributed to an increase in the atmospheric deposition of heavy metals and are probably the largest sources of inputs to soils. The spreading of industrial wastes, sewage sludge and river dredging on agricultural land is another source of heavy metal contamination. Sewage sludge is spread on around 1 per cent of total agricultural land, but the amount of sewage sludge applied to land is likely to increase when the dumping of wastes at sea ceases in 1998 because of the requirements of the EC Urban Waste Water Directive. Very high applications of inorganic fertilizer and animal manures can also increase heavy metal concentrations in soils. However, most of the pesticides that contain heavy metals have been withdrawn from use. Once in soils, heavy metals are immobilized almost indefinitely as the natural removal rate is very low. Remedial treatment to reduce contamination levels are available but can be very expensive and therefore requires careful consideration of the potential benefits to be accrued from the costs that will be incurred. Tackling heavy metal contamination in soils therefore highlights the types of choices and issues we face within the context of sustainable development, although it should be recognized that this is a significant problem only in very localized areas.

    WASTE

    1. Household Waste:
    2.  

    3. Industrial and commercial waste
    4.  

       

    5. Household waste recycling and composting:
    6.  

       

       

    7. Materials recycling:
    8.  

       

       

       

    9. Waste going to landfill

     

     

     

     

     

     

    1. Indicator shows recent trends in household waste are rising per capita, together with consumer expenditure per capita, and the composition of household waste It is important because sustainable development depends on positive action by individuals as well as by government or industry. Individuals can reduce waste not only directly, by recycling, reusing and composting where possible, but also through their actions as consumers, by buying long-life, re-usable, environmentally friendly products with minimal packaging. Household and similar wastes collected by local authorities also have a relatively high calorific value and are potentially a valuable source of energy.
    1. One of the most obvious ways in which households can minimize the amount of waste which has to be disposed of is to recycle items such as paper, glass, plastics, metal and to compost kitchen and garden waste. This indicator, which measures the proportion of household waste recycled, is an important measure of the extent to which individuals are prepared to take action themselves to help the environment. Indicator shows the percentage of household waste in the UK which is recycled or composted together with the target for the year 2000.
    2. Indicator shows the amounts of selected scrap metals and other materials recycle since 1984 in the UK as a proportion of consumption. Landfilling and incineration of wastes results in the loss of many tonnes of potentially reusable materials. Recycling of materials can contribute to the conservation of raw materials, reduce pollution from waste disposal and may contribute to reductions in energy use in and pollution from production processes where it replaces virgin materials.
    3. Energy from waste: Indicator shows since 1990 energy recovery from waste disposal and treatment processes and energy recovery from landfill gas projects. Where the environmental and economic costs of recycling are high, it may be better to recover energy from waste, either by burning it or by using the methane-rich gas which is generated as organic wastes decompose in landfill sites. Incineration of waste has a number of environmental advantages: it reduces emissions of methane which is a potent greenhouse gas, it reduces by up to 90 per cent the volume of waste which then has to be disposed of, and it converts waste into a material which is less biologically active and poses fewer potential risks for the environment. Using the gas produced in landfill sites reduces emissions of methane, a potent greenhouse gas, reduces local risks of explosion and enhances the restitution of landfill sites to other uses.
    4. A wide range of waste types can be landfilled safely and landfill may remain the only option for some inert wastes and for wastes which are difficult to burn or recycle. However, landfill sites do have the potential to release pollutants into the water and soil, and generate significant quantities of methane which is greenhouse gas.

    OVERSEAS TRADE

    1. UK imports and exports: Indicator shows UK imports and exports of food, wood, basic materials, manufactured goods, leisure travel and other services, and hazardous wastes.

     

    1. It is not possible to encapsulate the issues discussed above in simple quantified indicators. However, in conjunction with the indicators on consumption of UK resources, it is relevant to consider what proportion of the UK's consumption is met by imports and how this is changing, and also how exports contribute to the UK economy.

    MINERAL EXTRACTION

    1. Aggregates output
    2. Aggregates from wastes
    3. Mineral workings on land
    4. Land covered by restoration/aftercare conditions
    5. Reclamation of mineral workings
    6. Aggregates dredged from the sea

    ACID DEPOSITION

    1. Exceedences of provisional critical loads for acidity
    2. Power station emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides
    3. Road transport emissions of nitrogen oxides

    FORESTRY

    1. Forest cover
    2. Timber production
    3. Ancient semi-natural woodland
    4. Tree health
    5. Forest management

    AIR

    1. Ozone concentrations
    2. Nitrogen dioxide concentrations
    3. Particulate matter concentrations
    4. Volatile organic compound emissions
    5. Carbon monoxide emissions
    6. Black smoke emissions
    7. Lead emissions
    8. Expenditure on air pollution abatement

    OZONE LAYER DEPLETION

    1. Calculated chlorine loading
    2. Measured ozone depletion
    3. Emissions of ozone depleting substances
    4. CFCs consumption

    FISH RESOURCES

    1. Fish stocks
    2. Minimum Biological Acceptable Level (MBAL)
    3. Fish catches

    RADIOACTIVITY

    1. Radiation exposure
    2. Discharges from nuclear installations and nuclear power generation
    3. Radioactive waste arisings and disposal

    MARINE

    1. Estuarial water quality
    2. Concentrations of key pollutants
    3. Contaminants in fish
    4. Bathing water quality
    5. Inputs of contaminants
    6. Oil spills and operational discharges